Andrew Hodges

Andrew Hodges – Editor

Speculative fiction editor for fantasy, horror, and LGBTQ+ fiction. Big Five experience; trusted by bestselling & award-nominated authors.

Overview

I specialize in fantasy, horror, upmarket fiction with speculative elements, and novels with queer protagonists.

My sweet spot is the space between genre and literary fiction. I'm drawn to character-driven novels, weird fiction, stories where the setting comes alive, and fiction that engages with contemporary social, political, or ecological tensions. I particularly enjoy helping authors navigate difficult transitions: second books, novels in a new genre, etc. My approach is generally not the best fit for complete beginners or discovery drafts.

I've worked as a freelance editor or consultant for HarperCollins (Harper Fire imprint), Penguin Random House (Viking, Philomel, and Putnam imprints), Pan Macmillan, and for other traditional publishing imprints. Authors I’ve worked with include Hugo finalists (Kaliane Bradley) and New York Times bestselling authors, such as Alwyn Hamilton and Petra Lord.

Alongside working with authors, I teach the course Editing Fantasy Fiction for the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading.

I hold an MA from the University of Cambridge in History and Philosophy of Science (very useful for worldbuilding!), a PhD from the University of Manchester, and a certificate in Developmental Editing from the University of Chicago Graham School.

As a former cultural anthropologist, queer editor, and author myself, I am sensitive to publishing traditions beyond Anglo-American publishing. I love building relationships with authors across languages and cultures.

Please note: I do not provide guidance for first drafts. Manuscripts should be complete and revised before inquiry.

TESTIMONIALS

"The biggest value I received from Andy was in the way he helped me to deepen my entire story. He showed me where beats or characterizations I took for granted had gaps to a reader, or raised questions I hadn't considered."

—Robert Winter, Paranormal Romance/Urban Fantasy Author

​"Working with Andy made my debut novel better, and the results in distribution and reviews prove it."

—Nathan Wagner, Speculative Western Author

Services
Fiction
Dystopian Horror LGBTQ Fiction Literary Fiction Paranormal Romance Psychological Thriller Urban Fantasy Young Adult Fantasy
Languages
English (UK) English (US)
Awards
  • Honorable mention in Foofaraw's 2025 An Ordinary Contest for the story "Winter in the Poison Garden"
Certifications
  • CIEP Advanced Professional Member
  • PhD Social Anthropology (University of Manchester)
  • BA (hons) Natural Sciences: History and Philosophy of Science, University of Cambridge
  • EFA member
  • Club Ed Developmental Editing of Fiction Certificate
  • Developmental Editing, University of Chicago Graham School (Grade A)

Work experience

Self-employed

Aug, 2019 — Present
Developmental editing, copyediting, and proofreading of fiction for Big Five publishers, small publishers, and self-publishing authors. Developmental editing of cultural anthropology manuscripts.

Portfolio

Copy Editing
Call of the Camino: A Novel

Redfearn, Suzanne

Lake Union Publishing

Copy Editing
Listen Closely

Leon Egan

Harper Fire

Copy Editing
Queen of Faces

Petra Lord

HarperCollins Publishers

Proofreading
Thorn Season

Kiera Azar

HarperCollins Publishers

'Destined to be a romantasy sensation' – Katherine Webber ONLY THE SHARPEST WILL SURVIVE Sharp, funny, sexy and dangerous, and packed full of irresistible twists, Thorn Season is an unforgetta... read more
Copy Editing
The Notorious Virtues

Hamilton, Alwyn

Viking Books for Young Readers

Proofreading
The Delivery: A Novella

Hurwitz, Gregg

Thomas & Mercer

Copy Editing
The Naysayers: A Novel

Fenton, Liz

Little A

Copy Editing
Blade

Walker, Wendy

Thomas & Mercer

Copy Editing
Most Valuable Player

Woody, Amanda

Viking Books for Young Readers

Copy Editing
Under the Neon Lights

Vinson, Arriel

G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers

Copy Editing
Tea, No Sugar

Klein, Morgan

SRL Publishing

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment Book Coaching
Deadstream

Romasco-Moore, Mar

Viking Books for Young Readers

Copy Editing
I Am the Swarm

Chewins, Hayley

Viking Books for Young Readers

Copy Editing
Prince of the Palisades

Julian Winters

Penguin

Young Royals meets Red, White, and Royal Blue in this heart-pumping romance by award-winning author Julian Winters!When roguish Prince Jadon of Îles de la Rêverie is left in America to clean u... read more
Proofreading
If You Knew Me: A Novel

Miskowski, S.P.

Thomas & Mercer

Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Broken Mirror: Resonant Earth Volume 1

Sisco, Cody

Resonant Earth Publishing

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Falconsaga

Winter, Robert

Robert Winter Books

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Way of the Viper: The Samurai Cowboys - Book Two

Wagner, Nate

Creative Refinery LLC

Copy Editing
Copy Editing Editorial Assessment

Andrew has 6 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Orlando T.

Orlando T.

Mar, 2026

Pinned
I absolutely loved working with Andrew on my project. His feedback, review, and suggestions were all dead on the things that I had not even noticed. He was concise. He had explained everything thoroughly giving me the bigger picture of why his suggestions and or feedback would improve a section o...
Read more
G C.

G C.

Jan, 2026

Pinned
Dr Hodges editorial feedback was careful, exacting, and genuinely useful. He has identified structural and craft level pressures around POV discipline, narrative distance, and reader orientation and with clarity and specificity. His notes were grounded in craft rather than preference, which made ...
Read more
Gregory B.

Gregory B.

Jun, 2026

Andy hooked into what was missing in a later draft of my manuscript right away. His comments were detailed, relevant, and most importantly, he wasn't afraid to give a firm, constructive critique. I plan to work with him again in the future, and would recommend him as a developmental editor ten ou...
Read more
Mark K.

Mark K.

Apr, 2026

After my consultation with Andrew, I had a clear sense of what to do next. His feedback was sharp and thoughtful, and it got right to the parts that needed work without overexplaining. It helped me see the draft more clearly and figure out how to move forward.
Ahana H.

Ahana H.

Jan, 2026

Andrew has been very friendly and professional throughout the whole process. His insight into my work has been extremely helpful and has guided me onto the correct path towards literary fulfilment through various helpful suggestions, allowing me to see the potential in my word. A true blessing in...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Andrew and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Most recent contributions

Do you have a favorite resource for dealing with genre-specific editing?

For speculative fiction, the Mythcreants website and blog resources are amazing. I particularly like that they have clearly stated and interesting opinions and takes on content editing questions, such as the use of multiple points of view. (I know that fantasy authors can get quite trigger happy ...
Read more

Professionals similar to Andrew

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Eilidh L.

Helping you edit the book you were meant to write, not the one you were told to. Here for stories that defy norms.

Edinburgh, UK

100% reply rate

View profile

Kayla R.

Copyeditor/Proofreader for Fantasy & Sci-Fi, Speculative Fiction, & YA General Fiction. There's no greater adrenaline rush than copyediting.

Ajax, Ontario, Canada

100% reply rate

View profile

Lindsey H.

I'm a skilled developmental and copyeditor specialising in YA and middle grade fiction keen to help you craft a book readers can't put down.

Sydney NSW, Australia

100% reply rate

View profile