Allison O'Toole

Allison O'Toole – Editor

I have a decade of experience in comics editing and project management. I love character-driven stories, horror, and varied perspectives

Overview

I'm a freelance editor with experience across the comics industry: major direct market publishers (including Image Comics, Comixology, and DSTLRY), small press anthologies, web comics, and self-published creators. I'm most passionate about horror (especially gothic and monster stories) and slice of life, but comics that defy easy genre categorization are the most exciting!

No matter the genre, I work best with stories that prioritize characters and their relationships. Whether your story takes place in an office, the distant past, or a far-off magical world, we'll talk about what your storytelling goals are and how your characters help you achieve those goals. To me, those are the building blocks of the narrative: who are these characters and what are you using them to say? My role is to help you clarify your vision and communicate it to your ideal reader!

Comics are a visual medium, so my editorial feedback doesn't stop at scripts: I'll ferry your comic from outline all the way to finished lettering, providing feedback and project management along the way. Need someone to keep track of deadlines, organize files, and follow up with your collaborators? I'm your gal!

Here's what some previous clients had to say:

"Allison is a meticulous editor. Her notes are always really thoughtful, and given with enough freedom that it really inspires me to think on the note and approach it from a way I might not originally expect. My work is always better for having gone through Allison's hands!" -Nadia Shammas

"Allison was the first editor I worked with, and she has set the bar high! She was invaluable in getting the first graphic novel I worked on ready for print. She is insightful and precise in her editing, and I would work with her again in a heartbeat!" - Sam Beck

Services
Fiction
Comics & Graphic Novels
Languages
English (CAN) English (US)
Awards
  • Eisner Award: Best New Series (Public Domain)
  • Eisner Award: Best Digital Series (AFTERLIFT)
  • Ignatz Award: Outstanding Anthology (Shades of Fear)
  • Shuster Award: Best Anthology (Wayward Sisters)

Work experience

Self-employed

Mar, 2015 — Present
I've been freelancing as a comics editor and project manager since 2015!

Portfolio

White House Robot Romance

Zdarsky, Chip

DSTLRY

Developmental Editing
Public Domain Vol. 1

Chip Zdarsky

Image Comics

Syd Dallas is responsible for pop culture’s greatest hero: THE DOMAIN! But his sons Miles and David have a complicated relationship with both the creation and their creator. Can they convince ... read more
Developmental Editing
Dead Romans Vol. 1

Fred Kennedy

Image Comics

Arminius, a Germanic prince raised in Rome, has sworn vengeance against the Empire that butchers his people. He wants to make a queen of the woman he loves, Honoria, a fellow slave. Now fifty ... read more
Developmental Editing
The debut graphic novel from The Great British Bake-Off star and author Kim-Joy, Turtle Bread explores mental health and the power of friendship, community and, of course, baking!On her way ho... read more
Developmental Editing
Love and War

Wheeler, Andrew

Dark Horse Books

Developmental Editing
In Your Skin

Aditya Bidikar

Image Comics

Bollywood body horror collides with erotic obsession as a die-hard fan resolves to replace her retiring screen idol, blurring fantasy and flesh in a dark, intoxicating debut.Priyanka is a Boll... read more
Editorial Assessment

Professionals similar to Allison

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Katie B.

Literary Agent with 4+ years experience across SFF, YA, Children's and Graphic Novels. I love plot-driven stories with commercial hooks.

London, UK

100% reply rate

View profile

Matt B.

I'm a literary agent with more than a decade of experience in genres spanning science fiction/fantasy, nonfiction, and graphic novels.

Jersey City, NJ, USA

100% reply rate

View profile

Kim R.

Editor & former DC Comics/WB story exec with 10+ years shaping standout, character-driven books & scripts with heart, structure, & payoff.

Philadelphia, PA, USA

95% reply rate

View profile