Stacey Goitia

Stacey Goitia – Editor

Twenty+ years editing cozies, mysteries, sci fis, and more. I edit more than I'm paid for! Gentle, professional, detailed for your success.

Overview

Over three decades ago, I edited three friends' manuscripts all the way to the New York Times bestselling lists - and that was my first experience editing! I've been a business owner, an award-winning writer, and even a high school Language Arts and Visual Arts teacher. I have attended writers' conferences for decades all over the U.S. to learn the best ways to edit and write in order to help writers succeed in the industry.

For over twenty years, I have professionally edited all levels, from Editorial Assessment to Proofreading. My video, created a while ago, says I've been editing for eleven years. I'm probably fooling myself into thinking I don't have to do a newer video (don't I look the same?) but I have been editing for much longer now and continue to love working for Reedsy.

I'm a detail-oriented person and have been told I catch things no one else has. I'm also a teacher. I will show you what to do to succeed, from fixing pesky errors publishers look for to weed out writers to filling plot holes you didn't know you had, along with helping with characters whose traits may be unbecoming of a hero/heroine and aiding with anything else standing in the way of you getting published. Many writers get tossed aside simply because they don't know what publishers want, and unfortunately, they won't usually take the time to tell you. Most are just too busy. But I will.

I specialize in cozy mysteries, mystery-thrillers, and sci fi, but I have experience in romance, comedy, edgy mystery, coming of age, LGBTQ, and other mainstream fiction. Don't beat your head against a wall trying to figure out what agents and publishers want. I have built the experience to help you in ways few editors can! See below for book covers of some of my more recent (and some not so-recent) published authors.

Caveats: I will only help with query letters after I've edited your manuscript. I charge a discounted, flat fee. I am also unable to edit books with any AI usage, rape scenes, torture scenes, and suicide scenes because of past trauma, although if these subjects are merely mentioned or referenced, they are acceptable.

Services
Fiction
Coming of Age Cozy Mysteries Humor & Comedy Science Fiction Thriller & Suspense
Languages
English (AUS) English (CAN) English (NZ) English (UK) English (US)
Awards
  • WISRA National Winner, Second Place, May's Angel
  • WISRA National Winner, Finding Eloise
  • Three additional awards from various writers' conferences over five years ago
Certifications
  • Bachelors' in Journalism
  • Master's in Education
  • Bachelor's in Graphic Design
  • Master Teacher, AZ Teaching Certification

Work experience

Self-employed

Jan, 2010 — Present
As a young woman, I wrote articles for ten+ years for marketing companies and a family-owned eatery. I also owned a graphic design/marketing company called Graphicomm, making $175/hour. Raising two children with rare medical needs, I sold my high-stress business. I met three lovely ladies on their way to getting published and enjoyed editing their books, helping them become New York Times Best-Sellers. I also wrote five of my own novels and am published in an anthology. With a Master's in Education, I taught English, Creative Writing, Social Studies, Career Enhancement, Edgenuity, and Cross-Content Art to at-risk teens. My true roots are in editing, and I'm back to helping people bring out the best in their stories to get published. I have experience in Cozy Mystery, Mystery Series, Romantic Comedy, Science Fiction, Dystopian, Sci Fi Romance, Women's Fiction, Comedy Fiction, Magical Reality, Middle Grade Fiction, Horror, and more.

Portfolio

Made with Reedsy
Blissfully Unaware

Yeeles, Martin A

Bob's Your Uncle

Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Made with Reedsy
More to Love

Ancell, Joyce

Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Made with Reedsy
Veil Rising: Tales of a Teenage Saint Volume 1

Moore, Joshua M

Inside Joke Productions

Developmental Editing
Vengeance in Vermont (Moose on the Roof Books Book 1)

Stock, Bonnie

Moose on the Roof Books

Developmental Editing
Made with Reedsy
The Legacy of the Diamond King

Clark, Roy A

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Made with Reedsy
Wings and Wounds: The Dragon Doc Tales Book 1

Burkman, Dr. S. K.

Snapdragon Publishing Company, LLC

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Made with Reedsy
A Pretty Pickle: A Mulbury Mystery (Mulbury Mysteries Book 2)

Harvey, Juno

Mandurang Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Made with Reedsy
Goodbye to Boyhood: A Collection of Stories

Thomas, Spencer

By Spencer Thomas LLC

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Proofreading
Made with Reedsy
Squeaky Hatchling: A veterinarian with rather unusual patients (The Dragon Doc Tales: A Novelette)

Burkman, Dr. S. K.

Snapdragon Publishing Company, LLC

Made with Reedsy
DOG EAT DOG

Goodman, Steve

Independently published

Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Smitten in the Stars: A Corvus Squadron Novel

URBAN, A.S.

Independently published

Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Black Tuesday

Colebank, Susan

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Cashing In

Colebank, Susan

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment
Goodbye, Rebel Blue

Coriell, Shelley

Developmental Editing Editorial Assessment

Stacey has 47 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Shawntea G.

Shawntea G.

May, 2024

Pinned
Stacey has been nothing short of fantastic, not only incredibly responsive but she also helped with exactly what I needed. I looked for a developmental editor because I knew that something was missing from my story. I didn't want an editor who would just pat me on the back, I wanted someone to te...
Read more
Stacey G.
Shawntea is one of the most adept mystery writers I have ever encountered. She can write on the fly, is willing to take feedback and turn it into gold, and has been extremely insightful in her worl...
Read more
Steve G.

Steve G.

Mar, 2024

Pinned
Stacey not did a great job editing and reviewing my manuscript but she also made it a lot of fun. She gave keen insights and crucial feedback that only an editor with her experience can provide . I highly recommend her and would definitely use her services again in the future.
Tarun S.

Tarun S.

Dec, 2023

Pinned
Stacey is a pro. She did a fantastic job at developmental editing and proofreading while keeping the story and message of my manuscript intact. She tirelessly combed through my book, notifying me of what I needed to fix and letting me know what I did well, as a fun bonus. I have learned a lot abo...
Read more
Chris R.

Chris R.

Nov, 2025

Hiring Stacey Goitia was the best decision I made for my manuscript, and she exceeded every expectation. For anyone writing sci-fi or technothrillers with complex plots, her expertise is non-negotiable. She is truly an editorial powerhouse, exactly the dedicated professional the genre demands. S...
Read more
Stacey G.
Chris had one of the most fascinating and creative premises I've ever edited in sci fi technothrillers. His grasp of world building, deeply-layered characters, extreme plots and subplots, tying up ...
Read more
Patty L.

Patty L.

Nov, 2025

I had never hired an editor before and I definitely got lucky when I found Stacey. She is a true professional, honest, but tactful in her editing. I could kick myself for waiting so long because her work has improved my novel tenfold and I will work with her again with my second novel.
Stacey G.
Patty's unique novel will do so well! She was professional, receptive to comments and ideas, and really had a lovely Cozy with humor, creativity, and unique characters. I was so impressed with her ...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Stacey and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Stacey

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Rita Ray

Rita R.

As a seasoned copyeditor with experience helping writers reach their audience, I look forward to chatting with you about your manuscript! 📚

Toledo, OH, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Jenny Rarden

Jenny R.

13 years editing and proofreading, specializing in romance in multiple sub-genres, for everything from short novellas to 100K+ novels.

Kansas City, MO, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Oren Eades

Oren E.

I'm an editor for a wide range of books across many genres, including NYT and WSJ bestsellers, sci-fi/fantasy/horror novels, and more.

New York, NY, USA

100% reply rate

View profile