Polly Rosenwaike

Polly Rosenwaike - Editor

Ann Arbor, MI, USA

Literary Magazine Editor, Author Published by Doubleday, and Creative Writing Teacher. I specialize in literary fiction and memoir.

Request a quote
Verified identity


After completing my MFA in Fiction at The New School in 2009, I moved from New York to Ann Arbor, where I’ve taught creative writing and worked as a freelance editor for the past decade. In 2017, I became the Fiction Editor at “Michigan Quarterly Review,” the flagship literary journal of the University of Michigan. I very much enjoy selecting fiction and working with writers toward publication in the magazine. A story I edited will be published in the “Best Debut Short Stories 2020: The PEN America Dau Prize”anthology.

I’ve worked on academic manuscripts for a number of professors at the University of Michigan and other scholars in the humanities. I’ve also edited fiction, memoir, and poetry for McSweeney’s Publishing and Wayne State University Press, as well as a range of individual clients.

My story collection, “Look How Happy I’m Making You,” was published by Doubleday, and was named one of Kirkus Reviews’ “Best Short Story Collections of 2019,” Amazon’s “Best Books of 2019 for Literature and Fiction,” and Glamour’s “Best Books of 2019.” Fiction, essays, and book reviews have appeared in the “O. Henry Prize Stories,” “Glimmer Train,” “New York Magazine’s The Cut,” the “New York Times Book Review,” the “San Francisco Chronicle,” and “Lit Hub.”

My other professional experience includes working as an assistant to a literary agent and providing program management for arts and education nonprofits in Seattle and New York.

I look forward to working with you!


“Polly was a fantastic help in preparing my memoir manuscript for submission. She did an all-in-one job: line editing, copy editing, and inserting key questions at critical points in the manuscript to help me flesh out ideas where needed. I highly recommend her!”

--Mira Sucharov, author of Borders and Belonging: A Memoir (Palgrave, Macmillan, September 2020)

“Polly copyedited my debut novel The Fire in His Wake. It is a lengthy book, and she was fast, fastidious, precise and responsive, everything I’d look for in a copyeditor. She was a pleasure to work with and I recommend her highly.”

--Spencer Wolff, author of The Fire in His Wake (McSweeney’s, July 2020)

“A good chunk of being a writer is revising and polishing, but when a story gets to a certain point, the fixes become harder and harder to find. Polly helped me finalize my work—to get it to a place beyond where I had the capacity to take it. She corrected, repaired, and made suggestions, and along the way, gave me opportunity to consider larger revisions which I hadn’t before noticed. It was not a solo process but a true collaboration. She marked up my work. I accepted/rejected. Since this was my first book and really didn’t understand the editing and typesetting process, I really appreciated her patience and kindness and especially her encouraging remarks. At all points, it was obvious that she and I shared the same motive, we were both dedicated whole-heartedly to making my book the very best it could be.”

--Steve Hughes, author of Stiff (Wayne State University Press, 2018)

“Polly edited my debut short story “Summertime,” which was published by Michigan Quarterly Review. As someone new to publishing, I had no idea what shape the editorial process would take. From a handful of dramatic accounts that float on the web and find a way to one’s inbox, I assumed that the relationship between an editor and a writer was a fraught one. When I received Polly’s comments on my draft, I realized I had no reason to worry. Polly’s detailed notes revealed that she had read my story extremely carefully; it felt great to be understood so well! We had a pleasant conversation about the story in which we discussed what I wanted to do with the text and how a reader coming to it for the first time might react to it. At no point did I feel that as a new writer, I was not taken seriously. Polly is a meticulous, careful, empathetic reader and she wants each of her writers to find the best possible version of his or her voice. I feel grateful to have the chance to work with her—I now know what is that mysterious thing that makes a good editor.

--Mohit Manohar, debut short story selected for Best Debut Stories 2020: The PEN America Dau Prize (Catapult, August 2020)

English (CAN)
English (UK)
English (US)
Biographies & Memoirs
Humanities & Social Sciences
Literary Fiction
Short Story
Women's Fiction

Work experience

Fiction Editor

Michigan Quarterly Review
November, 2017 – Present (almost 5 years)

Lecturer in Creative Writing

Eastern Michigan University
January, 2010 – April, 2018 (about 8 years)

Freelance Editor

For Fiction, Memoir, and Academic Manuscripts, and for McSweeney's Publishing, Wayne State University Press, 5th Avenue Press, and others
October, 2009 – Present (almost 13 years)

Portfolio (22 selected works)

The Fire in His Wake

Wolff, Spencer


Whitney, Emerson

Invisible Ink

Stern, Guy

Doctor Levitin

Shrayer-Petrov, David, Shrayer, Maxim D., Bronstein, Arna B., Fleszar, Aleksandra I., Shrayer, Maxim D.

Transforming Harry: The Adaptation of Harry Potter in the Transmedia Age (Contemporary Approaches to Film and Media Series)

Alberti, John, Miller, P. Andrew, Howe, Andrew, Bausman, Cassandra, Cuntz-Leng, Vera, Dicieanu, Maria, McCain, Katharine, Butler, Michelle Markey, Potts, Liza, Turner, Kelly, Dallaire, Emily

Hell on Earth

Hameiri, Avigdor, Appelbaum, Peter C., Holtzman, Avner

A Prehistory of the Cloud

Tung-Hui Hu, Steve Toner, University Press Audiobooks

Reconstructing the Old Country: American Jewry in the Post-Holocaust Decades

Adler, Eliyana R., Jelen, Sheila E., Diner, Hasia, Adler, Eliyana R., Jelen, Sheila E., Lederhendler, Eli, Slucki, David, Krah, Markus, Estraikh, Gennady, Kellman, Ellen, Levitsky, Holli, Baskind contributor, Samantha, Ribak, Gil, Deblinger, Rachel, Komaromi, Ann, Jünger, David, Rothstein, Rachel


Reeve, Ava

Polly has 7 reviews

Communication & Punctuality
Communication & Punctuality

Papa Niang
I was glad that Polly agreed to take on my manuscrit. If I had a second book to review, I can tell you that I would be going straight to her. Thanks Polly for all the help ! Happy thanksgiving !

Papa Niang, November 2021

Enma Karina Elias
Polly provided such detailed, thoughtful and intuitive editing to my writing. I appreciated her ability to ask questions that helped me have 'aha!' moments within my writing. Truly a great editor to work with!!!

Enma Karina Elias, August 2021

Chelsea Waechter
This is now the second time I’ve worked with Polly and I would go back a million times over. She’s expeditious, kind and her edits are made with the utmost care and attention to detail. Thank you, Polly!!

Chelsea Waechter, October 2020

Chelsea Waechter
Polly was able to really help me home my manuscript with an incredibly thorough copy edit. She adhered to our timeline and was able to help answer my questions as anything came up. She guided me through with kindness and patience and I would be thrilled to work with Polly again in the future.

Chelsea Waechter, September 2020

Enma Karina Elias
Polly was punctual and professional, but above all her edits cut to the heart of my short story. Every question and suggestion she had was right on point and helped me really think about my work and what I was trying to accomplish. I HIGHLY, recommend working with Polly. In addition, she is generous and considerate in her care of your work. Thank you so much, Polly!

Enma Karina Elias, September 2020

Read more reviews

Explore the Reedsy Community

Reedsy is a community of top publishing professionals. Join Reedsy today to browse 1000+ profiles.

Alja Kooistra

Academic copy editor, proofreader, editorial project manager with 20+ years experience in the social sciences, humanities, and health

Livonia, MI, USA

Lisa White

As an editor with over 25 years' experience specializing in nature and memoir, I can help you take your project to the next level.

Boston, MA, USA

To view 1,000+ more profiles, Join Reedsy