Connolly Bottum

Connolly Bottum – Editor

Former HarperCollins editor specializing in editorial assessments, developmental edits, and book coaching for YA, MG, and romance novels.

Overview

Prior to freelancing, I worked as an in-house editor at HarperCollins for nearly five years. At the beginning of my time with the company, I edited romance novels for Harlequin Intrigue, Love Inspired, and Love Inspired Suspense before later becoming an editor for Inkyard Press, a children’s imprint of HarperCollins, which gave me the opportunity to edit many wonderful young adult and middle grade novels. I am proud to say that books I edited have won awards, become Indie Next picks, and been selected for several subscription book boxes, including OwlCrate, The Bookish Box, and Beacon Book Box, among others.

I specialize in editorial assessments, developmental edits, and book coaching since my favorite part of the editorial process is helping authors to ensure their story structures are as strong as possible. I love exploring new fantastical worlds and inviting authors to consider how they can make their contemporary settings feel more realistic, and I adore the puzzle-like process of figuring out how a novel could feel more cohesive and engaging.

I was raised in San Francisco but later moved to the East Coast to attend Amherst College, where I received a BA in Psychology and English with a concentration in Children’s Literature. After residing in New York City for several years, I moved back to San Francisco, where I now live with my Chihuahua mix, Jasper.

I look forward to hearing from you!

***

"Working with Connolly has been one of the highlights of my career. Connolly has a keen editorial eye and excels at helping writers play to their strengths, while never losing sight of their unique voice and perspective. She's also an amazing cheerleader—her encouraging notes make all the difference during the revision process. I've grown as a writer thanks to Connolly, and I would eagerly work with her in the future!" —Mara Rutherford, author of The Poison Season, Luminous, and the Crown of Coral and Pearl duology

Services
Fiction
Contemporary Romance Middle Grade Middle Grade Fantasy New Adult Paranormal Romance Romantic Fantasy Urban Fantasy Young Adult Fantasy
Languages
English (CAN) English (UK) English (US)

Work experience

Self-employed

May, 2022 — Present

Inkyard Press/HarperCollins

Oct, 2021 — May, 2022 (7 months)
• Acquired and edited 7-9 books annually for Inkyard Press, an imprint publishing young adult and middle grade novels, while also preparing materials for paperback editions of titles released previously in hardcover • Wrote copy for all of my projects, optimizing the voice and content for the intended audience

Inkyard Press and Harlequin Intrigue

Oct, 2019 — Oct, 2021 (about 2 years)
• Acquired and edited approximately 4-6 Inkyard titles and 8-10 romance titles annually

Harlequin/HarperCollins

Nov, 2017 — Oct, 2019 (almost 2 years)
• Worked as the departmental assistant for Harlequin Intrigue and Harlequin’s Subsidiary Rights and Audio team • Served as the editor for five authors who write for Love Inspired and Love Inspired Suspense

Dystel, Goderich & Bourret LLC

Jun, 2016 — Aug, 2016 (2 months)
• Read and evaluated over 200 queries to determine which manuscripts should be requested for further consideration • Wrote over 30 reader’s reports comprised of synopses, evaluations, and recommendations in order to highlight the strengths and weaknesses of manuscripts

Portfolio

A Forgery of Roses

Olson, Jessica S.

The Poison Season

Rutherford, Mara

Inkyard Press

Made with Reedsy
Gilded Wicked Mirrors

St. Lewis, Hazel

Hidden Siren

Heart's Gambit (Heart's Gambit, 1)

Myall, J.D.

Wednesday Books

Love Makes Mochi (Love in Translation Book 3)

Valentine, Stefany

Joy Revolution

Made with Reedsy
Grasping for Starlight

Hollis, Livvy

Livvy Hollis

Made with Reedsy
Queen of Spades

Wu, Katelynn

Katelynn Wu

Love Craves Cardamom (Love in Translation)

Avachat, Aashna

Joy Revolution

Love Requires Chocolate (Love in Translation)

Stringfield, Ravynn K.

Joy Revolution

A Multitude of Dreams

Rutherford, Mara

These Vengeful Hearts

Laurin, Katherine

You Truly Assumed

Sabreen, Laila

The Last One to Fall

Lepore, Gabriella

Every Time You Go Away

Johnson, Abigail

I Like Me Better

Weber, Robby

Sing Me Forgotten

Olson, Jessica S.

This Is Why We Lie

Lepore, Gabriella

Luminous

Rutherford, Mara

Connolly has 96 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Brooks W.

Brooks W.

Feb, 2026

Connolly was outstanding to work with. Her feedback was thorough, specific, and immediately actionable, and her notes showed real care for both story and craft. She’s professional, knowledgeable about the market, and generous with practical guidance on next steps. I left the edit and our call wit...
Read more
Haley L.

Haley L.

Jan, 2026

As someone new to the professional editing process, working with Ms. Connolly was a great introduction to developmental editing. She clearly explained the contract and made the experience easy to understand. Her feedback was thoughtful, detailed, and what I needed to improve as a writer. I appre...
Read more
Meghan M.

Meghan M.

Jan, 2026

Connolly was wonderful to work with. I hired her for a developmental edit of my romantasy genre manuscript, and she was very professional and responsive throughout the entire process. She set clear expectations and deliverables up front, was open to questions, and delivered the project in full an...
Read more
Aoibh W.

Aoibh W.

Jan, 2026

Connolly did a great job on my query letter review. I was happy with the results and the final deliverable. She had good insight into the proper format and approach to getting it sold.
Morgan N.

Morgan N.

Jan, 2026

Connolly did an awesome job. Great to collaborate with!

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Connolly and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Connolly

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Antonia Reed

Antonia R.

Former English Editor at Book on a Tree specializing in YA and speculative fiction. Career highlights include writing comics for Disney.

Nottingham, UK

100% reply rate

View profile
Hannah Close

Hannah C.

Experienced editor specialising in developmental editing and editorial assessments for fantasy and romance novels.

Newbury, UK

100% reply rate

View profile
Mary Novak

Mary N.

Developmental editor in spaces where fantasy and romance overlap: paranormal romance, fairytale retellings, historical fantasy

Old Tappan, NJ, USA

90% reply rate

View profile