Cindy Marsch

Cindy Marsch – Editor

I help make dreams come true – developing a plan after your first draft or polishing with personal care. Lower-cost options available.

Overview

Now scheduling projects for January 2026 and beyond - beginning with the Manuscript Assessment (MA). All clients should have a completed draft and desire to make substantial revisions to it. Fiction writers should have some experience with writing beyond school assignments, and memoirists should have both a significant message and a realistic understanding of their audience. I limit copy editing to projects for which I have first done developmental editing - the MA. Ask about a budget-sensitive consult or edit of a portion of your project.

"Cindy was professional, reliable, and most important, thorough. She gave honest feedback along with constructive critique [and] pointed out holes in my plot that I didn't know existed, while also helping me see my strengths. Her contributions to my work cannot be overstated." - T.B., a happy Reedsy client

I'm Cindy M., an author and editor with an undergraduate degree in creative writing (short stories primarily) and a master's in literature. I have been editing professionally for a decade and taught writing for more than three decades. I work with writers according to your needs, making the most of your strengths and following your direction. Because I am an author myself, I know you are looking for an editor who can enhance your own voice.

Do you have a draft and a dream but know your work is not up to your own high standard? My popular, economical Manuscript Assessment will give you a true overview of what is most promising and what needs most work as you revise. One potential client commented that my sample edit showed how I could take her modern romance "from garage band to gold record."

Can you trust me to help you realize your dream? Take a look at my Reedsy reviews below!

Note: Although I am open to some sensuality, violence, and strong language, I prefer not to edit extensive erotic content, graphic violent content, gratuitous strong language, nor occult material. Let's discuss your situation.

"I feel very fortunate to have worked with Cindy on both a developmental and copy edit of my manuscript. She is a consummate professional whose insightful feedback and suggestions helped transform my rough draft into a novel that I am excited to share. . . . Like any excellent teacher, Cindy is adept at asking just the right questions to prompt a writer to dig deeper into the 'why' of their craft. She makes you think, which is a good thing!" - R.F., a happy Reedsy client

Services
Fiction
Anthologies Cultural & Ethnic Historical Fiction Literary Fiction Short Story
Non-Fiction
Biographies & Memoirs Christian Non-Fiction
Languages
English (US)
Certifications
  • Alliance of Independent Authors Partner Member

Work experience

Self-employed

Oct, 2015 — Present
I am an author of historical, biographical, literary fiction and short stories thus far, with plans for contemporary fiction and maybe cozy mysteries in the years to come. I have found my favorite work offering professional editorial services, with enthusiastic acceptance from small presses and individual authors as soon as they see what I can do for them.

Grove City College

Aug, 2016 — Dec, 2019 (over 3 years)
(Still on the rolls for future need of the college.) Taught one or two sections each semester of Foundations of Academic Discourse in the Writing Department to freshman students from all academic disciplines. Curriculum included critical thinking, grammar and style instruction, and the principles of academic writing of several types: exposition, persuasion, synthesis, and critical review, with a professional standard and citation of sources.

Veritas Academy Online

Sep, 2010 — May, 2015 (over 4 years)
Developed and taught Composition 2 to students in grades 8-12 for this online school, helping students learn grammar, style, and basic essay forms for description, persuasion, comparison, and narrative. Much of my instruction was in the form of individual essay evaluation in extensive comments for each student.

Writing Assessment Services

May, 1996 — Jun, 2022 (about 26 years)
As a young mother watching the growth of homeschooling all around me and hearing the desires of homeschooling parents for quality writing instruction for their older children, I began teaching online when the technology allowed only exchange of simple files and emails. I developed many writing courses using the Great Books, ancient rhetoric exercises (Progymnasmata), and other high-quality resources, and in time I became a consultant for many private schools for their writing programs. In 2022 I sold my domain and instructional materials to another entrepreneurial writing teacher.

Florida State University, Auburn University, Tallahassee Community College, Los Positas College

Aug, 1982 — May, 1995 (over 12 years)
In these different colleges, taught courses including remedial writing lab, freshman composition, freshman article and essay workshop, sophomore literature, written business communications, and business report writing part time (FSU, TCC, LPC) or full time (Auburn University) intermittently through these years.

Portfolio

Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Red Bishop

Yuan, Robin T W

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment Book Coaching
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Armageddon 2029

Elsant, Martin

Independently published

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
IRON MEDICINE

Brady, Richard

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Copy Editing
The Gift of the Seer

Laugheed, K.B.

Copy Editing
Copy Editing Proofreading
Copy Editing Proofreading
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment

Cindy has 111 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Alessa M.

Alessa M.

Oct, 2025

Pinned
Working with Cindy was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Her developmental editing went far beyond surface-level feedback. She approached my manuscript with the insight of a true craftsperson, combining narrative intuition with a teacher’s depth of understanding. Cindy’s assessment ...
Read more
Cindy M.
Wow, I am so grateful for this glowing review! It is satisfying to connect with an author so thoroughly and to know I've made a real difference in getting the story out in the world in its best pos...
Read more
Bhupendra P.

Bhupendra P.

Sep, 2021

Pinned
This was my first time working with Cindy and right from the beginning, I loved working with her. She gave clear constructive feedback that helped me immensely. Her examples during developmental editing were greatly constructive for me. Cindy found issues that made me think clearly in words. She ...
Read more
Cindy M.
It was a delight to spend many hours with Bhupendra's beautiful book, and I am honored to have been a part of getting it out to the world. I trust many readers will enjoy his touching, humorous, de...
Read more
Michael R.

Michael R.

Aug, 2021

Pinned
Warsaw Fury was my second book working with Cindy. That by itself should really say enough. There's a reason I asked her to do an editorial review and copy edit, two extremely important edits in forming the story. Most importantly, Cindy is brutally honest and to the point. She doesn't sugarcoat...
Read more
Cindy M.
It has been a pleasure working with Michael. I actually developed my Manuscript Assessment service as we worked together on his first book, and it has proven to be one of the most valuable services...
Read more
Rose M.

Rose M.

Nov, 2025

Cindy was patient and very personable. She consistently encouraged me to look at my writing in new ways. She is very knowledgeable about style and writing conventions. I learned a lot from Cindy!
Cindy M.
It was wonderful walking alongside Rose as her story unfolded over time, and I will miss our near-weekly interactions!
Bill B.

Bill B.

Oct, 2025

Cindy provided my story with the exact review I was looking for. It provided me with a lot of work to do on my manuscript. In a developmental edit I hoped to get an understanding of the elements of my story, what worked and what didn't. Having spent a lot of time drafting I lost my ability to see...
Read more
Cindy M.
I appreciated Bill's patience as I dealt with a family medical crisis and then sought to work with him to find the best way forward for his complex project. I hope I have been able to clarify his v...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Cindy and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Most recent contributions

What factors do you take into account when setting your editing rates?

Over time I have come up with an hourly rate I need to make for active editing work, then I make an offer based on the time I expect to spend on a given project: A set per-word cost for a service like manuscript assessment that takes about the same time/effort for every client A sample copy or...
Read more

What steps can authors take to ensure an editor's communication style aligns with their needs, particularly when they are sensitive to criticism?

In your brief, explain this about yourself, and ask for sample edits. When you receive a sample, if a particular suggestion is troubling, ask the editor a good question about it. Let's say the editor changes your dialogue tags like "remarked" or "sighed" or "countered" to "said" across the boar...
Read more

How might authors start an autobiography with a compelling hook?

First, the autobiography should have a plot and a sense of the author changing over time as a good character would in a successful novel. And the core idea of that plot can be revealed from the earliest pages. Not "I was born in Philadelphia in the spring of 1961." But "I was born at Albert Ein...
Read more

Professionals similar to Cindy

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Sohini Ghose

Sohini G.

Edited and proofread 300+ books for Big 4 and indie presses, including Nobel laureate Mo Yan's, Pow! Proofreader at Harlequin. Author.

75% reply rate

View profile
John Irvin

John I.

Helping authors and publishers polish manuscripts with precision and care. I've proofed 150+ books since 2020—your words, ready for readers!

Pensacola, FL, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Brooke Maddaford

Brooke M.

Experienced (9 years in-house, 19 years freelance), nonfiction editor specializing in assessments, development editing, and copy editing.

Denver, United States

100% reply rate

View profile