Abby Muller

Abby Muller – Editor

Experienced, creative, comprehensive & encouraging editor specializing in queer and trans fiction and memoir. Previously: Algonquin, Abrams.

Overview

After eight years in traditional publishing, it's a pleasure to focus more closely on working directly with authors to hone, develop, polish, and share their stories. At present, I am available for editorial assessments and query letters.

I would describe myself as a hands-on editor who cares deeply about her authors and the stories they want to tell. My style is warm and collaborative as well as rigorous, thorough, and thoughtful. My editorial work tends to focus on development and continuity of characters and themes, with close attention also paid to structure, plot, and pacing (see below for some testimonials from my authors!). I always offer concrete, actionable feedback, and I also aim to ask questions that will help you discover new approaches to your manuscript as you revise.

I have experience across genres with a focus on queer fiction and memoir. I also love weird and unsettling novels, magical realism, coming-of-age narratives, and memoirs that braid many strands. I have enjoyed editing smart and engaging nonfiction about science, history, and culture.

In addition to years of developmental and line editing experience, I bring to the table a deep knowledge of how the traditional publishing industry works, and a desire to help demystify that black box for authors. As part of working together on any project, I'm glad to discuss industry questions you might have. My prices include a follow-up Zoom or phone conversation post-edit.

TESTIMONIALS

"Abby has a gift for seeing a manuscript as a system of moving parts, and thereby identifying precisely what needs to be fixed. The greatest joy of the whole writing process was going back and forth with her in the Track Changes comments. She is such a funny, engaged reader, and I felt newly excited about my novel when seeing it through her eyes."

—James Frankie Thomas, author of IDLEWILD

"Abby's detailed editorial letters covered everything from plot, character, and prose to how to better incorporate backstory, knowing exactly which issues needed attention and what questions to ask to make me dig deeper. Working with Abby was having an encouraging, wise, and committed partner who could see my vision and knew how to guide me through the murkiest waters."

—Jennifer Savran Kelly, author of ENDPAPERS

"Abby is the editor you need for your narrative nonfiction work. She's got that rare trifecta of storytelling skill, journalistic judgement and a willingness to dive into tough subjects to tease out the best details. Her way with words is smart and clear, and she'll ask you the questions you need to improve your manuscript. What's more, she's patient, kind and a pleasure to work with."

—Charlie Wells, author of WHAT HAPPENED TO MILLENNIALS

Services
Non-Fiction
Biographies & Memoirs Humanities & Social Sciences
Fiction
Coming of Age Contemporary Fiction LGBTQ Fiction Literary Fiction
Languages
English (US)

Work experience

Self-employed

Sep, 2024 — Present

Abrams Books

Jun, 2022 — Sep, 2024 (over 2 years)
I acquired and edited trade nonfiction and fiction books, working with authors to develop, hone, and polish their projects through multiple rounds of feedback, including intensive line edits and detailed editorial letters. I worked most frequently on literary and upmarket fiction, memoir, and popular narrative nonfiction on science/history/culture topics. I am passionate about promoting queer voices, particularly with trans, nonbinary, and/or sapphic perspectives.

Algonquin Books

Sep, 2016 — Jun, 2022 (over 5 years)
I acquired and edited fiction and narrative nonfiction, building my own list and working with executive editors. I also screened submissions for the Publisher & Editorial Director, submitted books for book awards, proofread all public-facing copy, and worked on a range of administrative tasks that gave me an excellent bird's-eye view for the holistic publication process.

Portfolio

Open Wide: A Novel

Gross, Jessica

Harry N. Abrams

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Cactus Country: A Boyhood Memoir

Bossiere, Zoë

Harry N. Abrams

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Idlewild: A Novel

Thomas, James Frankie

The Overlook Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Pioneer Summer: A Novel (The Pioneer Series)

Silvanova, Katerina

The Overlook Press

Copy Editing
The Adult: A Novel

Fischer, Bronwyn

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Naked: On Sex, Work, and Other Burlesques

Feast, Fancy

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Ibis: A Novel

Haynes, Justin

The Overlook Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Endpapers: A Novel

Savran Kelly, Jennifer

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Dazzling: A Novel

Emelumadu, Chikodili

The Overlook Press

Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Clean Air

Blake, Sarah

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Eli Harpo's Adventure to the Afterlife: A Novel

Schlich, Eric

The Overlook Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Daughters: A Novel

Capes, Kirsty

The Overlook Press

Copy Editing
The Mountains Sing

Quế Mai, Nguyễn Phan

Algonquin Books

Editorial Assessment
Holler Rat: A Memoir

Liftig, Anya

Abrams Press

Developmental Editing Copy Editing
Pump: A Natural History of the Heart

Schutt, Bill

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Copy Editing
Inside the Wolf: A Novel

Rowland, Amy

Algonquin Books

Developmental Editing Copy Editing Editorial Assessment
Editorial Assessment
Let's Get Back to the Party

Salih, Zak

Algonquin Books

Editorial Assessment
Editorial Assessment
Editorial Assessment

Abby has 8 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

JOLY F.

JOLY F.

Jun, 2025

Pinned
Working with Abby was hugely helpful. She provided excellent advice. Her insights into my project were spot on, and she was generous with her written responses. In short, Abby gave me new directions to work toward and fresh approaches to my writing. Thank you Abby.
Teya R.

Teya R.

Mar, 2025

Pinned
This is my second time working with Abby, so I knew what to expect (excellence!), and I was not disappointed. Abby is thorough, but kind. She points out areas for improvement and offers helpful advice, but also notes strengths and things she liked, which is so important given there is a tremendo...
Read more
Nathan A.

Nathan A.

Mar, 2025

Pinned
Abby was an absolutely wonderful editor that was both careful and compassionate. This being my first time seeking editing services for a work of fiction, I was blown away by the professionalism, quality, and clarity in which the edits and suggestions were made and received. I would certainly reco...
Read more
Jennifer M.

Jennifer M.

Oct, 2025

I have gone to Abby with three different tasks and have been very happy with the results each time. Her notes and thoughtful, clear and concise.
Lillian K.

Lillian K.

Aug, 2025

I have enjoyed working with Abby to improve and polish my query letter to agents. She has an interest and understanding of prisons (the subject of my memoir) that shows in her comments and recommendations for my query letter. She is kind and gentle with her suggestions which as a new writer I app...
Read more

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Abby and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Abby

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Anne Stockwell

Anne S.

I'm a former LGBTQ+ Editor in Chief with a film background and years of success nurturing star writers and beginners. Let's tell your story!

Los Angeles, CA, United States

100% reply rate

View profile
Maartje Scheltens

Maartje S.

Experienced and friendly non-fiction editor with a passion for bringing your research and ideas to a wide audience. **AVAILABLE AFTER JUNE

Cambridge, United Kingdom

100% reply rate

View profile
Andrew Hodges

Andrew H.

I focus on fantasy fiction, thrillers, & LGBTQ fiction. Commercial and literary. Developmental & line editor. Honest, kind, supportive.

Edinburgh, UK

100% reply rate

View profile