Sue is a beloved wife, friend and mother of two who, unlike most people, enjoys rainy days: she dances with her soon-to-be husband under the rain, she gets excited when it pours rain during her daughter’s soccer practice, she finds comfort in a storm as she dies surrounded by her family.
After Sue’s untimely passing, she shows up as rain during the family’s milestones. Although she realizes that this ruins the celebratory occasions, she still wants to be part of those precious moments that were taken away from her by cruel fate.
The premise of Rain on Sunday is ingenious and full of potential. The magic works well and the ending, in which Sue’s spirit finds a way to be with her loved ones without disrupting their lives, is uplifting. There are nice vignettes of domestic life, and the characters are likable, if rather plain.
I loved how the prologue ties to the short story that follows. In the former, the author tells a personal childhood anecdote about one rainy afternoon when her father took her on an adventure. It is always intriguing to discover how real-life events and experiences can inspire writers.
The story is categorized as young adult fiction, but it doesn’t quite fit in that realm. In spite of the great premise, the plot is simple and fairly predictable, and the situations and characters are not complex enough to address with much depth the troubles that two young siblings would experience after the premature death of their beloved mother.
Rain on Sunday seems more like a very nice children’s story that happens to have two young adult characters. Contemporary YA readers possess enough smarts and life experiences—good, bad and in-between—to expect more multifaceted, challenging narratives.
Despite its promise and strengths, this story ultimately falls somewhat short. It lacks spark; it lacks thunder.