Enjoying this book? Help it get discovered by casting your vote!

Must read 🏆

Mesmerizing fiction that reads like real life—an unputdownable mystery! Masterfully written, relatable, intertwined characters of precision.

Synopsis

HERE THERE IS NO WHY by Philip Graubart
Synopsis

Did Chaim Lerner, acclaimed Israeli writer and Holocaust survivor, kill himself in 1983, thirty-eight years after surviving Auschwitz? If so, was it traumatic memories finally catching up with him? Or despair over Holocaust denialism? Or ordinary, difficult health issues - an aching hip, a damaged knee? Or an episode of depression, which had dogged Lerner even before the Germans invaded Cracow, his hometown?
Or, was it murder?

What a story! "Here There is No Why" will be counted as one of my top five reads of 2024. If you didn't know better, as a reader, you would think this book is non-fiction! Completely relatable characters, family life, flaws, intrigue, mystery, questions of God, the Holocaust, and suicide. A well-rounded juggernaut of historical and contemporary issues.


This book is wholly satisfying. It will keep you guessing. Even when you think you have it figured out, you might still be surprised by its ending. Everything about this book is top-notch. Once again, I have encountered a book that should be turned into a television series or a movie. The discussions raised would benefit a wider audience than readers alone.


"Here There is No Why" will have a permanent place on my bookshelf. It is a book I wish to rebut with its theological discussions despite it being fictionalized. Where is there a group for me to join where questions of God are meant only to lead you closer to Him? Where you are not judged for the queries or schools of thought raised but a safe space in which all can be explored. School is not always the answer, but a small group can be. This book, then, is perfect for book clubs and for those in religious circles who are unafraid to come up with answers to tough questions, especially as they relate to the Holocaust.


I am thoroughly impressed with Phil Graubart's writing. I am a new fan. While I often criticize the use of swearing in books, drinking, sex outside of marriage, etc., in this book, all that usually causes me a personal affront is done tastefully, entirely in character, and not used to the point of saturation that is just as unnatural as a book with perfection instead of the truth of humanity after "The Fall."


From the origin story behind the words "Here There is No Why" to how this phrase appears a handful of times throughout this book's pages, these words will stay with you and have you pondering life long after reading. Books that linger have the potential to change a reader's perspective, and books that teach are books with staying power that should be rewarded with no less than a full five-star review. Thank you, Phil Graubart, for the gift of your words. My hat's off to you!



Reviewed by

Reading books and writing reviews brings with it every emotion under the sun; forever changing, forever changed, and I wouldn't have it any other way. May my words not only help fellow readers but also the authors of the books we read.

Synopsis

HERE THERE IS NO WHY by Philip Graubart
Synopsis

Did Chaim Lerner, acclaimed Israeli writer and Holocaust survivor, kill himself in 1983, thirty-eight years after surviving Auschwitz? If so, was it traumatic memories finally catching up with him? Or despair over Holocaust denialism? Or ordinary, difficult health issues - an aching hip, a damaged knee? Or an episode of depression, which had dogged Lerner even before the Germans invaded Cracow, his hometown?
Or, was it murder?

September, 2023

R u going to funeral

           A text from my daughter. I was drinking wine and watching NBA highlights when I felt the vibration in my too tight jeans. The buzz was lengthier, more insistent than an email alert – clearly a text. Probably the pharmacy, I thought, or a social security senior scam. Not urgent enough to take the trouble of removing my phone from my pocket, at least not until the second annoying reminder. I reached for the phone, winced from the pain in my wrist – a tennis injury – and saw it was from Hannah.

I took a moment to admire the prose. It was a masterpiece of literary economy. Sixteen letters, no punctuation, no italics, no bold lettering. Yet she evoked stabbing memories of the most significant moments in my life, including the horror-filled nights and days after Hannah discovered the hanging body of her own mother, my wife. Suicide. Heartbreak. Depression. Illness. Mystery. Sex, virginal and otherwise. Romance. Racism. Genocide. God. Evil. Good. Hannah’s non-sentence somehow touched on all the obsessions that defined my life and career. It summoned forgotten odors: Jerusalem pine, garbage on the streets, Israeli shampoo, Time Cigarettes. And distant, nearly forgotten sensations: falling asleep to the sound of breaking waves, cold nights with no heat, the erotic jolt from watching young female soldiers. I’d won a Pulitzer Prize, written eight books, dozens of long think pieces, hundreds of op-eds, a play, even a handful of poems, and I never achieved anything as brief, powerful, painful, and to the point as Hannah’s brief text.

I stretched, wincing again, for the remote and muted the TV. I studied my phone. Was I going to the funeral? Well maybe, if only to make sure the old lady was really dead. Like Hannah, like thousands of others, I’d gotten the word the night before. Zehava was enough of a legend and her family had enough clout to override the Jewish Israeli tradition of burying the body as soon as possible. Zehava’s corpse would have to wait three long days until all the dignitaries could arrive from the four corners of the earth.

All the dignitaries – and me and Hannah? I texted back the first excuse I could think of. “Too expensive?” I wrote. The question mark left the door open. It was an opening bid. In a game I knew I would lose. That, come to think of it, I probably wanted to lose.

“I’ll pay,” she wrote back, almost instantaneously, even before the three dots danced across the text balloon.

“new covid outbreak” I wrote, thinking I could also dispense with punctuation and capitalization and still get my point across. The pandemic was officially over, but there were rumors of a new wave. Surely that was a valid excuse for me, an asthmatic man in his sixties (alright, just sixty-one).

This time she took three seconds to respond. The dots danced. “business class,” she wrote back. And then, in a fresh balloon, “Don’t worry about the money.”

Was that a bribe or a counterargument? Was business class somehow virus resistant? Or was she remembering how much I bitched about the plane ride the last time we flew to Israel seventeen years before, when she’d just turned 15. “Probably too late to make reservations,” I wrote.

Again, no dancing circles. An immediate response. “Already done. Paid for. Tomorrow.”

I laughed out loud. My rich daughter. Married to a Silicon Valley venture capitalist. My son-in-law holding wealth I wouldn’t be able to count. Leader of a company I couldn’t describe, no matter how many times he’d explained it to me. So much had changed since the last time. But not everything. She’s still telling me what to do. Anyway, I’d already decided to make the trip, coach or business class, with or without Hannah. Michal wanted me to go. She had something to tell me. That was motivation enough.

Comments

About the author

Rabbi Philip Graubart is the author of Planet of the Jews, Silwan, Rabbis and Gangsters, Women and God and several other novels and essay collections. His new novel Here There Is No Why will be published in October, 2024. view profile

Published on October 22, 2024

Published by Koehler Books

80000 words

Contains mild explicit content ⚠️

Genre:Mystery & Crime

Reviewed by