DiscoverHistory

Cleopatra's Nose: Randomness in History

By Jakob Sjolander

Enjoying this book? Help it get discovered by casting your vote!

Loved it! 😍

A lively look at the randomness all around us, that occasionally stumbles as it goes exploring…

Synopsis

History. It’s a mess.
Chaos rules world history, and many times the smallest things have had vast effect. Again and again the course of history has been pushed in one direction or another, like a feather in the wind. Over thousands of years, even the most unlikely event becomes likely.
Nothing is certain except uncertainty.
Learn how:
1. A dropped helmet destroyed an empire
2. A coin toss decided the fate of Hollywood
3. A scientist forgets to clean his plates and discovered penicillin
4. And much, much, more!
After writing two books on mankind’s failed attempts to predict the future, Jakob Sjolander turns to the reason why we fail: Randomness.
Imagine a world shaken by assassinations, scandals, mutated viruses, wars, and serendipitous discoveries. That world is our own. The idea of history’s stately march is an illusion caused by our knowledge of the present. Randomness lurks everywhere, always ready to pounce on our attempts to rationalize our world.
See the true madness of history rather than the tidied-up version taught in school.

I don’t know if it’s true, but the tale of how, commanding a Russia submarine during the Cuban Missile Crisis, one Vasily Arkhipov refused to press the nuclear button, always gives me a pleasurable shiver. If nothing else, the story gives us the sense that individuals can make a difference. And the central idea of this book that the title, Cleopatra’s Nose, points at is that there is: 


…not just the randomness of history, but a specific kind of randomness. Namely, the randomness caused by individuals.


The book starts with a rather brisk summary of why physical science is full of unlikely coincidences and logical curiosities, but, as I say, to me it is the human aspect that is more intriguing. When Jakob Andreas Sjölander Johansson writes that events like the disagreement on the submarine rule world history, it resonates more than to talk of the inscrutable randomness of the universe.


Philosophically, though, this book is a bit of a ramble. For exampe, in a war, it is not true that a surprise attack will seem to the victim as "random" – rather it is a "surprise". Conversely, in physics, there is more randomness than suggested here: an element of randomness in even the most everyday things. Johansson doesn't mention it, but the orbits of the planets around the sun are chaotic, as the gravitational pulls of moons and planets can potentially perturb each other - causing (for example) Mercury to hurtle towards the Sun.


“The butterfly effect could be likened to a crossroad”, writes Johansson, explaining that someone could choose to be influenced in a significant choice simply by their observation of a butterfly. But this is not the original idea. It is an interesting, a curious take, but it is not the idea. The butterfly effect is about the dynamics of the atmosphere, which are unpredictable at a certain scale. Yet (like the circling of the planets), there is a uniformity. Which is why, when I wave my hand in the air, I really do not need to worry about causing a tidal wave in the Atlantic. Or, as Johansson puts it, the butterfly can change the weather, but not the climate.


On the other hand, a feature of the book is that it does outline just why science is not quite as simple, not quite as cut and dried, as the popular summaries would have it. To show this, the illustrations offered are varied and thought-provoking - like the tale of the Codex Argenteus, the “Silver Bible”) - but the assertions are sometimes too easy. “We will always find that 2 + 2 adds up to 4”, says Johansson, which indeed is something of a standard claim - but the certainty is only that of tautology - saying the same thing twice, and true by definition. Or consider this claim in the book: “The third reason why societies are less vulnerable than individuals to randomness is that larger entities usually consist of smaller parts, and that the whole can survive without these parts.” If it were this easy, then there would be no ‘butterfly effect’. Undaunted, Johansson goes on to draw grand, political conclusions from his argument, saying: “Thus, divisions within a society, between subgroups, classes, cities, regions, corporations, and various levels of government, provides (sic) some protection against randomness.” 


The example of a path through a forest is more appealing. At first, the line of the path is rather random. But over time “it is easier to walk where others have gone before” and eventually, a trail emerges, and then a road, maybe with bridges. 


Thus, randomness often destroys itself and gives rise to order in the long term.


Later, however, we are told that while people following each other is usually a good idea, it becomes a problem “if everyone does so”. I'm not sure what Johansson had in mind when he wrote this, but it’s a garbled thought. Presumably, the problem is people following each other off the cliff-edge – like lemmings, as he also says. If everyone follows good advice, where is the problem?


A related confusion is over the merits of large and small groups. 


The more radical a group is, the smaller it is likely to be – fortunately, I might add. And the larger a group is, the more moderate it is likely to be.


I can guess what the author means, but history offers us the example of the Nazis, or the Bolsheviks, or the Cultural Revolution in China, all very large groups, with the radicalism increasing as they crushed rivals. Johansson wafts away such possibilities with the observation that sometimes “a small subgroup” seizes power and abuses the larger group for its own purposes.


This is an unusual book, a thought-provoking look at randomness. But yes, at times, the content can be a bit random too.

Reviewed by

Martin Cohen is an author specializing in popular books in philosophy and social science. His writing ranges widely as he likes to make connections between different areas and ideas. Recent books include 'Paradigm Shift’ two ‘for Dummies’ books and a look at food, called, ‘I Think Therefor I Eat'!

Synopsis

History. It’s a mess.
Chaos rules world history, and many times the smallest things have had vast effect. Again and again the course of history has been pushed in one direction or another, like a feather in the wind. Over thousands of years, even the most unlikely event becomes likely.
Nothing is certain except uncertainty.
Learn how:
1. A dropped helmet destroyed an empire
2. A coin toss decided the fate of Hollywood
3. A scientist forgets to clean his plates and discovered penicillin
4. And much, much, more!
After writing two books on mankind’s failed attempts to predict the future, Jakob Sjolander turns to the reason why we fail: Randomness.
Imagine a world shaken by assassinations, scandals, mutated viruses, wars, and serendipitous discoveries. That world is our own. The idea of history’s stately march is an illusion caused by our knowledge of the present. Randomness lurks everywhere, always ready to pounce on our attempts to rationalize our world.
See the true madness of history rather than the tidied-up version taught in school.

1 – A Very Brief History of Randomness from the Big Bang to Corona

Around 13.8 billion years ago our universe came into being with a “Big Bang.” In the first second, gravity and all other laws of physics were fixed.[i] If any of these laws had been a tiny bit different, the universe as we know it would not have been possible. If, say, hydrogen had transformed into helium in a way that converted 0.006% of its mass to energy instead of 0.007%, no such transformation could have taken place and we would have a universe containing nothing but hydrogen. But if the rate of conversion had been 0.008%, we might have had a universe entirely without hydrogen.[ii] The odds of the laws of physics ending up exactly the way they did border on the impossible. Some physicists believe that there have been trillions upon trillions of universes, and this one just happened to be suitable for humans.[iii]

           Billions of years later, 66 million years ago, the earth was struck by an asteroid. It wasn’t very large – just 10 kilometers across. The earth is 12.800 kilometers across, so the asteroid was about the size of a BB pellet to a two-story house.[iv] But, unlike a BB pellet, the asteroid left a crater some 40 kilometers deep. That is four Mount Everests.

           Luckily, such impacts are rare. On average, they occur once in 500 million years. That is a long time, even in cosmic terms. Also, the asteroid hit one of the worst spots imaginable, with just the right (or wrong?) geology to cause a truly terrible disaster.[v] If the asteroid had arrived half an hour later, the spin of the earth would have caused it to hit a less sensitive spot. But it didn’t. Instead, the asteroid hit the reset button of life on earth. When the smoke cleared, mammals turned out to have done less badly than most life-forms, and their main competitors, the dinosaurs, were gone. We humans are the descendants of these mammals.

           Another big jump forward brings us to a mere 70,000 years ago. Humans had already been around for 130,000 years, but now we were an endangered species. Through genetic studies, we can see that all living humans are descended from just a few thousand individuals. Our numbers might have declined by nearly 99%.[vi] Why did this happen? Nobody knows for sure. Yet we pulled through.   

           The next jump brings us into living memory. In 1962, the Cuban Missile Crisis risked turning the Cold War hot. A small flotilla of Soviet submarines was ordered to sneak past the American blockade. When one of the submarines was discovered, the American navy dropped practice-depth charges to force it to surface. Not knowing that the charges were of a practice variety, the submarine captain concluded that war had broken out and panicked. He decided to fire the submarine’s secret weapon – a nuclear torpedo.

Fortunately, one Vasily Arkhipov was also aboard. Though Arkhipov was only second in command of the submarine, he was curiously enough the commanding officer of the flotilla. That meant that his permission to use the nuke was needed. After a heated argument, he refused to give that permission.[vii] Nobody knows what would have happened if Arkhipov had chosen differently.

           Events like these rule world history. They are not even uncommon. It is wondrous that mankind ever came into being, and ever more so that we stayed that way. Over the billions of years since the Big Bang, the hundreds of millions of years of life on earth, the few hundred thousand years of our own species, and the thousand-year history of civilization, infinite things could have happened that would have ensured that no one would be around to either write or read this book; or do anything else, for that matter. That we are here is a great stroke of luck. Tragically, it required that an endless number of alternate universes never came into existence.   

           This book is an investigation of the randomness of history. As I hope to show, history is littered with examples of the smallest and strangest things having huge consequences. In 323 BC, Alexander the Great’s greatness was cut short when he became sick and died at age 32. In the 15oos, King Henry VIII’s wish to divorce his wife led to England’s divorce from Catholicism. In 1941, mold on a cantaloupe was discovered to create large amounts of penicillin and thus saved hundreds of millions of lives.[viii] In 2019, a typo in the genome of a Chinese bat virus started a pandemic. The history of the world could and would have been very different if not for these things and billions of others. Let us take a look at just a few of these. 


[i] Bill Bryson. A Short History of Nearly Everything. Black Swan. (2016)[2003]. Chapter 1, page 28.

[ii] Ibid., page 35.

[iii] Ibid., page 34.

[iv] Sean B. Carroll. A Series of Fortunate Events: Chance and the Making of the Planet, Life, and You. Princeton University Press. (2020). Chapter 1, page 21.

[v] Ibid. Page 31.

[vi] David Lockwood. Fooled by the Winners: How Survivor Bias Deceives Us. Greenleaf Book Group Press. (2021). Chapter 7, page 115.

[vii] Priscilla Roberts. Cuban Missile Crisis: The Essential Reference Guide. ABC-CLIO. (2012). Entry: “Arkhipov, Vasili Alexandrovich (1926–1999).”

[viii] Bill Bryson. The Body. Doubleday. (2019). Chapter 3, section 3, page 43.

No activity yet

No updates yet.

Come back later to check for updates.

Comments

About the author

Jakob Sjolander has searched for oil in Canada, worked on farms in Australia and been a schoolteacher in a high-crime neighbourhood. He holds a master's degree in philosophy, and has written books on courage, failed predictions, animals, and randomness. view profile

Published on November 29, 2022

50000 words

Worked with a Reedsy professional 🏆

Genre:History

Made with Reedsy
Learn more
Reviewed by