FeaturedBiographies & Memoirs

A Grafted Tree: A Memoir of Adoption, Disability, Identity and Family

By Kathleen Tumminello

Enjoying this book? Help it get discovered by casting your vote!

Loved it! 😍

A story of parental love, learning, and advocacy for children with disabilities and homosexuality outweighing discrimination and danger

Synopsis

In A Grafted Tree, Kathleen Tumminello shares her experiences raising three very different children. Together, she and her husband formed an inter-racial family through adoption, became pioneering advocates for a child with learning and developmental disabilities, embraced a son who came out as gay, and mobilized an extended family to save their daughter from an abusive boyfriend who had assumed near total control over her life.

Written with immense vulnerability, honesty, and love and set against her own memories of an idyllic childhood in a small Massachusetts town, Kathleen’s memoir captures countless moments of joy amidst the daily challenges of parenthood that will inspire all of us.

A Grafted Tree by Kathleen Tuminello is a collection of short stories about her life as a mother and advocate for her three children. After having their son Matthew, Kathleen and her husband Jack adopted a daughter named Melissa and a son named Jason, both from Korea. Melissa suffered from burns and failure to thrive and required attention to her disabilities to be successful in childhood. As she grows up, Melissa and her parents must develop boundaries that allow her to be as self-sufficient as possible while still trusting and leaning on her parents as needed. Kathleen and Jack must learn to help Melissa with her learning and physical disabilities as well as Jason’s attention disorder. The story covers dark topics without overdramatizing the realities of weathering a society built for an archetype of people that your children do not fit the mold of. 


It is easy to say “Here is what I did to be successful at raising my children”. It is much harder to write a story that gets into the gritty part of reacting from a place of emotional distress or discovering that your child was facing barriers years into their struggles. Kathleen’s book is successful because it teaches readers how to learn from and advocate for their children coming from someone who has been there and made mistakes. Emotions and settings are well described. Readers learn to think of a backyard as a secret hideaway sheltered by trees and of cities as a place of freedom because they house resources needed desperately by Melissa to be her true self. 


The jumps around in the timeline are sometimes hard to follow. The book discusses homophobia, suicidal ideation, abuse, domestic violence, and other hardships in a way that is not graphic and should be suitable for most readers. While there are a few more relaxed chapters about the characters when they are kids, most chapters involve facing hardships and can be emotionally charged. It might be nice to include a couple of chapters of the family dynamic outside of the major events to paint a fuller picture of what providing and enjoying life with adult children looks like in the family. Matthew’s hardships are not recognized until adulthood and it would benefit A Grafted Tree to see more of the advocacy for him that was seen in Melissa’s and Jason’s stories.  

Reviewed by

I am an avid book analyst. My passion will help build community with other readers and help authors articulate the meaning behind their books.

Synopsis

In A Grafted Tree, Kathleen Tumminello shares her experiences raising three very different children. Together, she and her husband formed an inter-racial family through adoption, became pioneering advocates for a child with learning and developmental disabilities, embraced a son who came out as gay, and mobilized an extended family to save their daughter from an abusive boyfriend who had assumed near total control over her life.

Written with immense vulnerability, honesty, and love and set against her own memories of an idyllic childhood in a small Massachusetts town, Kathleen’s memoir captures countless moments of joy amidst the daily challenges of parenthood that will inspire all of us.

Fall 1979


“You would think I’d remember every detail of that day, but my memory can only dispense fragments; a kitchen corner where the wall phone hung, a scrap of paper, some scribbled words, a simple question, and a pitiful image in my mind. So, I suppose that’s where the story begins.

         I had just hung up the phone and was looking at the words I had jotted down while trying to listen to everything that I had been told:

         malnourished

          failure to thrive

          burns lower body

          doesn’t speak

          head shaved

          about 2-3 years old

          can’t leave behind

          beautiful

All words written in pencil…as if they could be erased.

      I held that scrap of paper with those unsettling words and gazed out the kitchen window. It was a beautiful fall day. I needed to think. Looking at the trees and the patches of sunshine on grass beneath them put me in a calmer state of mind. Sunny days made me feel optimistic, upbeat, and happy, but this was different…I couldn’t be deceived by the sun. Did I stand there for one minute? Ten? Twenty? I don’t know. I only remember not wanting to call Jack. I wanted to be alone with my thoughts first. The clear day had morphed. It became mist-laden, and through the gauzy vapor an image had emerged—a baby—burned, abandoned, and languishing. The image kept trying to overwhelm my thought process. Fighting through the haze, I returned to what Jean, our adoption caseworker, had just told me. “I know you and Jack were hoping for a healthy infant, but I thought you might be interested. This is a special case.” It was a special case, but what about my career? I was a newly registered nurse, an RN just getting started with hospital nursing. But this baby…that image…I turned away from the window and picked up the phone.

         “Jack? They found a little girl for us.”

         “That’s fantastic! How old is she? What did Jean say?”

          “She said her friend, Connie Boll, who’s a social worker, was in Seoul looking for a baby for a client. She found a little boy, but then came across a little girl with burns.” With a shaky hand, I picked up the piece of paper and quickly told Jack what I remembered. I took a deep breath and paused. “The problem is Connie thinks the little girl is a failure-to-thrive baby and doesn’t want to leave her behind.”

         “What’s failure to thrive?”

         “Well, when babies don’t get enough attention or care, some give up. They become passive and stop learning how to do all the usual things babies do—you know, like sitting up, crawling, and walking.”

         “So how serious is this?”

         “If no intervention occurs…the baby can die. That’s why Connie’s so concerned.” There was silence on the other end of the phone. I couldn’t see Jack’s face to judge any reaction he was having. So, winding and unwinding the phone cord around my finger, I continued telling him what I had pieced together from my conversation with Jean.

         “Jean told me that Connie had suffered from burns on her neck as a child, and that was one reason she was drawn to the baby. She said the baby is beautiful, and she’s developing a bond with her.”

         Still silence on Jack’s end.

         “Oh, and Jean also said the little girl seemed to have a fear of men, and it might take a while for her to warm up to you.”

         It was a lot of information for us both to process. The moment had come: me in the corner of a sunny kitchen, and Jack at his office desk. Did we want this child? Matthew, our eleven-year-old, was in middle school and doing well. He had a gentleness about him and knew we were waiting for another baby. However, Jason, our four-year-old, also adopted from Korea, was a handful. His hyperactivity kept us both entertained and challenged. So, the question remained: Did we want this child? Could we do this?

         After a long pause, Jack asked one question. “Does she make eye contact?”

         “Yes,” I said.

         “Well, that’s good enough for me,” he replied.

         I don’t remember a single second of the rest of that day.





Excerpt From

A Grafted Tree

Kathleen Tumminello

This material may be protected by copyright.




No activity yet

No updates yet.

Come back later to check for updates.

4 Comments

Joan AttianeseLoved this well written book
0 likes
about 1 year ago
Nancy CloverBeautifully written. These lines from the book sums it up - "It's easy to fight for yourself. It's downright emotional to fight for your child." The book brings you on an emotional rollercoaster while routing for this family and Melissa!
0 likes
about 1 year ago
Selma WritesI’m so happy to be able to review this book here for all to see. It’s my greatest pleasure : I give it a whopping 5-star What strength, what compassion! Honest, I couldn't put it down... The mark of a truly great book is whenever I’m done reading it, I continue to think about it. In the case of this book, A Grafted Tree, A Memoir of Adoption, Disability, Identity, and Family by Kathleen Tumminello—emotive prose, heart-achingly selfless, warm, and vivid representation of adoptive parents with huge hearts who, like any parent, are looking for inclusion for their children—I kept turning the pages fast, hoping to get to the end sooner to find out just how this story ends (for now, as it’s ongoing). This book spoke to me with compassion and resonated with my mother’s heart and by the end of my first “fast” read-through, I found good purchase at how the “situation” was resolved. The ending is most beautiful—how I like stories to end, and now this book occupies a special spot in my heart and shelf. Knowing this, I set to reading the book one more time to savor each line of this literary memoir. Now I could understand the analogy and genius of the title. Now I could “feel” the intimate words expressed by this Author and hold her in a sisterly embrace for her resilience and the unconditional love she and her husband blessed us all with when they took to caring this much for their adopted children and biological child. It must have been hard but I also feel that a love like the one that shone silently on each page is exemplary for our world. We need more humans like these. “Nature vs. nurture—the age-old conundrum. What makes us who we are? It’s both, you might say. I agree, but when I set out to write this memoir about raising an adopted child with disabilities, I found that nature played a far larger role than I expected. I also discovered that this story is not about adoption, disabilities, or even raising children. It’s about accepting one another for who we are and understanding and valuing our differences and identities.” ~ quote in Author’s Notes The main focus in the book is on the beautiful daughter. What strength! Much like a butterfly’s metamorphosis. I cannot tell you how much I appreciated the positive vibes that sprouted within me from reading this memoir. I’m confident you’ll find similar vibes sprouting too. And it’s my hope that books like this will encourage more social awareness and sensitivity to people with disabilities—every child deserves to be accepted and valued. I can’t recommend “A Grafted Tree” enough—a resounding 5-star rating from a satisfied customer in Japan. may this review help you decide to purchase to read. Fly little book, fly!
0 likes
about 1 year ago
Patricia DeveauxLoved this book. A perfect picture of a growing and changing family. Pulls you tight in to life
0 likes
about 1 year ago
About the author

Kathleen Tumminello is a retired Occupational Health Nurse who lives in Boston, MA with her husband Jack. view profile

Published on November 28, 2023

50000 words

Worked with a Reedsy professional 🏆

Genre:Biographies & Memoirs

Made with Reedsy
Learn more
Reviewed by