Enjoying this book? Help it get discovered by casting your vote!

Worth reading 😎

If you like historical fiction and music, you will appreciate this book.

Synopsis

In a world mired in bigotry and hate, Elazar, a young Jewish violinist in search of redemptive love and transportive music, survives World War II in the Soviet Union.

Drifting back and forth between Ukraine and Uzbekistan between 1922 and 1944, Elazar navigates wedding-night steam rooms and birch-branch floggings; rivers of refugees and rivers of blood; lice and typhoid and refugee tent camps; horse-drawn carriage rides through betrayal and death and flattened shtetls; and the small luxuries of the desperate, a simple plate of chicken and cabbage.

But in this literary symphony, there is always, always, the ebb and flow of music, weaving in and out of a life lost in the terrifying wilderness, searching for family and home.

With its romantic war-era setting, layered characters and captivating love story, readers care about learning if the hero finds what he is looking for.

This historical fiction novel spans several decades and follows the Gershovich family, specifically Elazar. At the beginning of the book, Elazar is only twenty-two and feels it is impossible he will find love in the small town he lives in. Most books about World War II take place in France or Germany, but this one takes place in Russia and gives a different viewpoint on how people were affected by the war in this country. After surviving a violent riot against Jews, or "pogrom", in 1903, the Gershovich family worked to rebuild and remain close-knit. They are bound together by their love of music which plays a huge role throughout the story. As the decades go on, the War hits and we see how it affects the people in this part of the world.


Whenever World War II is involved, there is rightfully a lot of focus on the Jewish people. This novel starts before then so you get to know and love the characters as the story progresses. The chapters are short with dates, so pay attention closely to see how swiftly time moves. The title, The Reluctant Conductor, comes from the idea that Elazar's father is the head of their family. He guides them with their hardware store business, everyday life, and with their music. Elazar does not want this job and fights it at every turn. He wants more in his life than what his small town can offer. It is beautiful to see how Elazar's character develops throughout the book. He is so young in the beginning as you can see through his actions and feelings. As time moves forward, he becomes more mature and experiences different events with his father that allow Elazar to see him in a new light. You get the sense that he will understand his father's role and perhaps fulfill it at some point.


This interwoven idea of music throughout the story, adds a taste of beauty amidst destruction. One of my favorite quotes about this happens between Elazar and his father. His father says, "Music is the language of feelings because we have so many feelings that we don't have enough words to explain. Music has many more tools to explain what we feel. To be a deep human being, it is essential to study, as it deepens your ability to know what true love is." p76


My only critiscism is that there were some key events that happen towards the end of the story that are never resolved. For example, what happens to Elazar's nephews? Adding something about this towards the end would really help round out the story. Other than that, the writing was beautiful and the story is one that has not been told often.

Reviewed by

Hi! I am a first-grade teacher and a busy mom of two boys. My passion is reading, grammar, and language. I love reading in my spare time and writing reviews that help support the books I love.

Synopsis

In a world mired in bigotry and hate, Elazar, a young Jewish violinist in search of redemptive love and transportive music, survives World War II in the Soviet Union.

Drifting back and forth between Ukraine and Uzbekistan between 1922 and 1944, Elazar navigates wedding-night steam rooms and birch-branch floggings; rivers of refugees and rivers of blood; lice and typhoid and refugee tent camps; horse-drawn carriage rides through betrayal and death and flattened shtetls; and the small luxuries of the desperate, a simple plate of chicken and cabbage.

But in this literary symphony, there is always, always, the ebb and flow of music, weaving in and out of a life lost in the terrifying wilderness, searching for family and home.

With its romantic war-era setting, layered characters and captivating love story, readers care about learning if the hero finds what he is looking for.

Prologue

7 July 1922 — My papa is flourishing his pipe like a conductor’s baton. Smoke wafts through the dining room as he finishes his usual diatribe with: “It’s all about family,” then stares at me. I squirm like a violinist who has lost his rhythm. “Are you with us, Elazar?”

        It’s Shabbat, Friday evening, I’m twenty-two years old, and I’m home in Kalarash poking at the sodden remains of my chicken and matzah balls. I unloaded boxcars full of rocks, bricks and lumber all week with my brother Herschel and I hurt all over. Mama gives me a calming smile as she rises to clear the table. Sarah snaps to and helps.

        “It’s a complex arrangement,” I say.

        “Keep practicing,” he says.

        When I was three, we lived in Kishinev, about fifty kilometers to the southeast. During Passover/Easter weekend that year, the Christians waged a pogrom on the city’s Jewish population. In our case, that means they ransacked our store, set our house on fire, murdered my sister, and my baby brother and they threw me off the roof.

For real.

While pogroms have happened for hundreds of years all over Europe – from Barcelona to Prague – this happened in the 20th century. Initially, it was a global scandal wherein politicians from America and all over were outraged and demanded justice. But punishment for the perpetrators came to little or no avail, and because countless, more outrageous atrocities have since occurred, to most of the world, the Kishinev Pogrom of 1903 has been swept under the carpet.

Not to us.

I don’t know how or why any of us survived but that’s why papa and mama, Toiva and Polina Gershovich, uprooted our family, packed up the business, and fled to this shtetl—this Jewish prison.

        In Kalarash, life is simple. Most people are Jewish. We speak Yiddish. Herschel and I went to yeshiva, Jewish school, where we studied Hebrew, the Torah and Talmud, from which the rabbis taught us to live every day like it’s your last. To that end, they say number one: have some fun, two: try to do some good, and three: don’t screw anyone over too badly, as you may be meeting your maker that evening. So that’s what we do. We go to the Synagogue, we celebrate Yom Kippur, Hanukkah, Passover, whatever, and nobody tries to kill us. 

Not everybody here is Jewish. It’s only been in recent memory that it’s become a shtetl. There are a couple of monasteries nearby that were built in the 1700s, even a cathedral, and with that, amicable goys, non-Jews, who speak our region’s book-end languages: Romanian and Ukrainian. Unlike in Kishinev, papa maintains a low-key presence here—he’s not politically active. But with the farmers, dairymen and former vintners, our family is respected, and we socialize amongst one another.

        Papa is fifty-three, and while he finds solace here, giving up our store, our house, our horses, and his whole life in Kishinev has taken its toll. He has trouble sleeping, he has a stiff lower back, and he treats Herschel and I like strivers. Yet, in nineteen years he’s fought and clawed his way back. We still don’t have horses, but we own our properties—our house and the store—and we pay taxes to the King of Romania.

 Mama is fifty-one, and to this day I don’t know all the details, but there is no question that the pogrom and the exodus from Kishinev scarred her for life. She looks old for her age and while she’s loving and ultra-protective, there is deep-seated pain in her facial expressions, the husky tone of her voice and the hunched over way in which she walks.

While our family has managed to rebuild our life out here in the heartland of Bessarabia, the big downside for me is there are very few girls my age, and I’ve known all of them since I was a child. I’ve dated several, gone through the usual coming-of-age milestones, but now dating any potential female mate in Kalarash seems incestuous.

In my life there is percussion in day-to-day work, the rise and fall of the sun, the coming going of the seasons. There is rhythm in family, eating meals, and celebrating holidays; but alas, there is no beauty, no high notes, no intimacy… no melody.

Comments

About the author

The writer of six plays including the critically acclaimed Out Late, as well as High Time, Chicken and Fish and Prairie Fire, TIM TURNER has also written an original screenplay, a libretto, adapted two of his plays into screenplays. The Reluctant Conductor is his debut novel. view profile

Published on February 02, 2024

Published by

50000 words

Contains mild explicit content ⚠️

Genre:Historical Fiction

Reviewed by