The year is 1896. Sherlock Holmes meets Thomas Edison. At the dawn of Cinema, a beautiful Broadway danseuse is murdered in Edisonâs New Jersey Laboratory. Irene Adler encounters ghosts on Broadway. Harry Houdini mystifies the New York Vaudeville circuit. Holmes and Watson go hunting in New York Cityâs Badlands with Police Commissioner, Theodore Roosevelt. Meanwhile, Rachel Holmes journeys to the Pine Barrens to film the Jersey Devil and the denizens of Poughkeepsie reel in Kipsy the Hudson River Monster.
The year is 1896. Sherlock Holmes meets Thomas Edison. At the dawn of Cinema, a beautiful Broadway danseuse is murdered in Edisonâs New Jersey Laboratory. Irene Adler encounters ghosts on Broadway. Harry Houdini mystifies the New York Vaudeville circuit. Holmes and Watson go hunting in New York Cityâs Badlands with Police Commissioner, Theodore Roosevelt. Meanwhile, Rachel Holmes journeys to the Pine Barrens to film the Jersey Devil and the denizens of Poughkeepsie reel in Kipsy the Hudson River Monster.
Mr Sherlock Holmes
âI saw the angel in the marble and carved until I set it free.â Michaelangelo.
Â
His fleeting smile graced his lips. At once I was reminded that this was the only outward show of feeling this great man once permitted himself. If my friendship meant anything it was how Holmes allowed me in and also allowed some cracks in the marble he affected as the dark persona of Sherlock Holmes.
Holmes was in truth not as impenetrable as he seemed. He was as malleable as any human man in this time and place could be. And for some reason, he regarded our friendship as a chance to explore those areas he hitherto fore denied, disqualified, ignored, or buried in order to breathe into life the gentleman he was meant to be, the Great Detective, Sherlock Holmes. When I met him, he had not completely donned the mantle of his persona. I had access to that young man filled with hope and excitement for his discoveries. At one time, I alone knew the real Sherlock Holmes. The man who ran towards me, a stranger, in Bartâs Chemical Lab with a test tube in his hand, laughing and shouting, his eureka:
âIâve found it! Iâve found it! I have found a re-agent which is precipitated by haemoglobin, and by nothing else!â
Â
The gentleman I recently encountered in his Baker Street digs, was incapable of such feeling. It was as if the mask he wore as protection from the horrors of his chosen profession had taken possession of him. That fleeting smile was all that was left of my robust and happy friend. The only crack in his persona. He still had that sardonic and witty humorous view of life, but the joy had gone out of it and everything else. It was fifteen seasons from that first meeting, yet he seemed older than his forty-two years.
I entreated him to find a way to defeat this nervous prostration, to come away with me to the country and offered every available piece of our great islands to no avail. And as before I worried about his cocaine usage and how it could impart a permanent pathological and morbid weakness in him. I thought of Freud, who had once before helped Holmes recover from the ravages of cocaine. But because of our present political situation, Vienna was out of reach to Englishmen.
Madame Irene was away on her Continental concert tour and would not return home for at least a month. Miss Rachel had left us to complete her degrees at Vassar College. Meanwhile, Holmes was not even opening his mail. I asked permission to do so and he waved an assent. Halfway through the pile of admonishments and appreciations, there was a cable from New York which grabbed my attention. It was a dire message from Thomas Edison, beseeching Holmes to travel to New Jersey as soon as it was safe to cross the Atlantic. There had been a murder at his motion picture studio.
This was it! My answer. Edison possessed a mind as capable and brilliant as Holmes. Would he not be able to rouse my friend from this insatiable darkness? America was the place Holmes had healed after his horrible year battling Moriartyâs henchmen in Europe. The year he said he became like them, an assassin. His six weeks in Poughkeepsie, New York cured him, brought him back to himself, and even opened his heart to love.
âWhat is it, Watson? Revelation is written all over your face,â said Holmes.
âIt is a message from Thomas Edison, requesting your presence at his New Jersey Laboratory. It seems a prominent danseuse was murdered in his film studio.â
âNew Jersey? Ireneâs birthplace?â
âYes, Edisonâs Lab and new film studio are in the town of West Orange, across the Hudson River from Manhattan Island.â
I picked up my copy of the steamship tables.
âThe next Lucania voyage will be in April.â
âWatson, that leaves us a month.â
âYouâre going, Holmes?â
âOf course!â
And here I witnessed that transformation I have spoken about before. He rose from his depression, and suddenly slipped on his cool persona, as carefully as he did his gloves. Before me stood the gentleman of action. I alone knew with what effort he had accomplished this and understood that for Holmesâ complete recovery, this trip to the States was an absolute necessity.
âWe just have time for some little research, Watson. Now, where was that paper?â
Holmes collected the Pall Mall Gazette from the carpet and scanned the advertising notices.
Â
Â
If you are a Sherlock Holmes fan, or drawn like the quintessential hive dweller to MX Publishingâs output, do not claim a complete knowledge of the depth of that niche genre until youâve read Gretchen Altabefâs Sherlock Holmes: Five Miles of Country. The tale, largely set in the New York City/New Jersey area differs in characters and dialogue from most previous works. To avoid spoilers, I wonât reveal more specifics about the plot than can be found in the authorâs synopsis.
Written in a different voice than most John Watson chronicles, the 1896 romp is a tightly researched plot that pulls the Baker Street detective into the birth of movies in the United States. The nascent art form is new, as is the homicide method. Yet, more impressive is the authorâs handling of the real history that surrounds a fictional dancer's death.Altabef rolls in a cast of familiar celebrities such as the New Jersey-based inventor Thomas Edison, Vaudevilleâs Harry Houdini and Theodore Roosevelt, a commissioner who tamed the NYPD, peppered with fictional women.
The novel introduces a different role for Holmesâ heartthrob Irene Adler and a previously unknown myth-chaser Rachel Holmes. Adler whom Doyle debuts in âA Scandal in Bohemiaâ in 1891, is always a sort of white whale for the famous detective. Altabef marries the pair as a means to add notions of Holmes as more of a real man rather than a male that views women as a distraction. Also, the fabled opera singer turns producer and touches on the real racial segregation that existed on Broadway during Americaâs Gilded Age and ghostly haunts along the Great White Way. Rachel Holmesâ pursuit to film a creature said to inhabit the Pine Barrens of southern New Jersey adds to the bookâs step away from male-dominated sagas where women tend to be rescued or rotten.
Five Miles of Country's mystery is solid, and its murder resolution is clever. Readers who wonder what prompted the author will find the answer in the Acknowledgments in the final chapter. âWriting is the art of creating something from seemingly nothing,â Altabef declares. âThe ânothingâ is the invisible magic of synergistic synthesis that goes on inside the artistâs mind.âÂ
This fresh take on so many elements that could have been stale is a pleasurable read. Those who give it a try will want more.