DiscoverNature

Birds and humans: who are we?

By Ruth Finnegan

Enjoying this book? Help it get discovered by casting your vote!

Loved it! 😍

Birds are incomprehensibly old by comparison to humans. But how much can we learn from them?

Synopsis

What are we humans? and our role in planet earth?

Urgent questions for today.

How do we humans - only one species after all - relate, for instance, to that older species, birds, those arguably equally talented, if different, creatures? How does their evolution compare with that of humans? and their social lives, parenting, tools, navigation, intelligence - have we, or indeed had we, something to learn from them? Was it they who discovered music, for us to emulate, and do they too have notable intellectual capacity, complex memory, aesthetic sense, and joy in play? And what, here millions of years before us, have they taught us humans?

In a startling complement and riposte to Harari’s stunning “Sapiens” and similar best-selling books that tackle the questions we now rightly ask ourselves about the development of human society in the dawn of history, “Birds and Humans” sets out an engaging, beautifully written, counter theory about the place of humans. It is one that needs urgent attention today. What can we learn from birds about our guardianship of this beautiful planet? and above all, do we, should we, share it with the million-years-old, experienced, assembly of birds?.

There are three kinds of people. There are those who are completely indifferent to birds; those who are fascinated by them and will happily spend all day in a wood looking or an unusual one – and those like me, who who like birds, but know little about them. This is a charming, informative tale aimed at the latter two categories, that is both at ‘twitchers’ (who already know a lot about our feathered friends) and the general reader with a broader interest in nature and the mysteries of the world about us.


Starting with perhaps the most amazing thing about birds. Which is how old they are as a life-form. Ruth Finnegan explains that they are indeed, the last of the dinosaurs, survivors of the Cretaceous–Palaeocene extinction 66 million years ago. It’s a mind-bogglingly long lineage. And she adds:


“…birds have lived on this earth and developed their skills and - as we shall see - their highly wrought culture, millions and millions of years before the emergence of human beings, and then in the early years of human history lived”.


She emphasises that birds are very much social beings, not only in parenting and nurturing their families, but “in working, playing, migrating, navigating, flocking - in short in living, being - together”.


With this in mind, the book poses the apt but unexpected question of the extent to which human beings have learned from, or at least have been in part inspired by activities they first saw among birds. For example, Finnegan asks:


“Was it birds who discovered and cherished music for us to emulate? And their lives as social beings, in their joint parenting, intricate home/ nest building, tool using, navigation, coordinated action, territoriality, joy in play, communication, adaptation to climate change and more ?”


What we can say, is that birds and humans share some core behaviours. Both birds and humans “form social groups with complex vocal inter-communication” and “both usually care for their offspring for an extended period of time”. And typical bird behaviour, just like typical human behaviour, includes “cooperative living, nest building, and two-parent care of the young”.


It’s a fascinating thought – and a very different way of looking at the world. Add to which, birds are essentially social and cultural beings and as such, “like humans, learn and pass on knowledge from generation to generation”.


In fact, Finnegan says, there is something of a mystery about how birds communicate. The phenomenon of birdsong is obvious, but the exact mechanisms of murmuration – where birds fly in huge, tightly packed, flocks, is less clear, and phenomenal like the almost instantaneous spread of the skill of pecking at milk bottle lids to get at the cream has puzzled experts for decades. 


The book is offered as a kind of tribute to David Campbell Callander, an Irish naturalist who knew a lot about birds, but it is gently written “in the common parlance” rather than the jargon of experts. It is illustrated too, with many colourful photos, but at time, to be honest, these seem rather random and I think the text actually would have been served better by fewer images, perhaps even in the form of specially commissioned line drawings. Perhaps an idea for a new edition!


The book closes with this entreaty:


“…here we are, two great branches of living beings, not identical but close, parallel, to a degree independent, to a degree interacting, with much in common but each with our own uniquenesses and of equal worth. It is given to us both, surely, to cherish and care for our beautiful earth.”


Reviewed by

Martin Cohen is an author specializing in popular books in philosophy and social science. His writing ranges widely as he likes to make connections between different areas and ideas. Recent books include 'Paradigm Shift’ two ‘for Dummies’ books and a look at food, called, ‘I Think Therefor I Eat'!

Synopsis

What are we humans? and our role in planet earth?

Urgent questions for today.

How do we humans - only one species after all - relate, for instance, to that older species, birds, those arguably equally talented, if different, creatures? How does their evolution compare with that of humans? and their social lives, parenting, tools, navigation, intelligence - have we, or indeed had we, something to learn from them? Was it they who discovered music, for us to emulate, and do they too have notable intellectual capacity, complex memory, aesthetic sense, and joy in play? And what, here millions of years before us, have they taught us humans?

In a startling complement and riposte to Harari’s stunning “Sapiens” and similar best-selling books that tackle the questions we now rightly ask ourselves about the development of human society in the dawn of history, “Birds and Humans” sets out an engaging, beautifully written, counter theory about the place of humans. It is one that needs urgent attention today. What can we learn from birds about our guardianship of this beautiful planet? and above all, do we, should we, share it with the million-years-old, experienced, assembly of birds?.

A Preface

Who are we? It is a question indeed - and thank you for wondering about it too, joining me as I try to pursue the question. Your companionship is so welcome.

Actually it is many questions. Who are we, we humans? where did we come from? are we separate and distinct from all other species or might we understand ourselves better if we see ourselves in perspective, in relation to other species of the past or present in this beautiful earth that we inhabit?

In the present crises of our planet these questions are more and more pressing. There is now an impressive range of books in response, such as Harari’s striking Sapiens and Homo deus. They  consider the dawn of history, the destiny of humankind and - perhaps most challenging of all - our responsibility for planet earth.

The present book is both a complement and a riposte to these accounts. It is understandable, indeed up to a point right, to consider the world from our own perspective , humanly, our eyes firmly fixed on ourselves. 


But in our current predicament we need to go further as well, to look more widely. We need in particular to look back to the time when millions and millions of years ago that great meteor struck, the world’s creatures changed, and the avine pterodactyl species started to emerge. They are with us still, now as those talented creatures we know as birds.

As becomes clear in this book they are indeed different from humans ( you need only glance at the pictures here, or, better, around you). But - this is the salient point - as the present account shows birds also have far far more in common with us than is usually recognised.

 This has two results. 

First, it helps to set human life in perspective. Perhaps after all we are not quite the unique distinctive species we regularly see ourselves as, the unquestioned Lords of the Earth? Others were here first with comparable, though not identical, skills and characteristics.

Second, remember that birds have lived on this earth and developed their skills and - as we shall see - their highly wrought culture, millions and millions of years before the emergence of human beings, and then in the early years of human history lived in close interaction with them - considering all this it is right to ask what the effect of this close conjunction might have been?

It was a long time ago! So any conclusions may have to be, in part at least, speculation - but actually no more speculative than other accounts of early human history and with arguably better evidence, for it is all around us. It seems inescapable that we should at least ask whether human beings , themselves blessedly innovative and learning beings, might not have learned much from, or at least have been in part inspired by, some, maybe many, of the practices they saw among birds. 

It is not foolish to look at how their evolution compares with that of the human species or wonder whether, here millions of years before we humans emerged from the sea or wherever, the birds might have proved a model for humans to have learned something, copied something, from them. Was it birds who discovered and cherished music for us to emulate? And their lives as social beings, in their joint parenting, intricate home/ nest building, tool using, navigation, coordinated action, territoriality, joy in play, communication, adaptation to climate change and more ? Have they shown , do they still have, a more harm-free care of the earth than we humans, something from which we might learn?

Let us then take a look at birds, those amazing, talented, creatures, here millions of years before us and perhaps - this is the surprise - with more in common with humans than we ever suspected. There is much learn.

What started off these thoughts of mine? Read on. You are entitled to ask … 

No activity yet

No updates yet.

Come back later to check for updates.

2 Comments

John HuntGreat book! Birds and Humans: who are we? by David C. Callender, is a book that delves into a refreshing perspective on birds. It crosses several 'genres' and levels in education and is also a great read by anyone interested in the natural world. David Campbell Callender is the pen name of Ruth H. Finnegan, an anthropologist and academic and expert writer who explores unusual topics. This book delves into the study of birds, their nature, evolution, their behavior, communication, language, culture, and art. The detailed study of the species is valuable not only as an introduction for readers new to the topic, but also for deepening aspects for bird lovers. I was especially amazed by the unique behavior and personality of these animals. Throughout the book, the information is enriched with beautiful photographs and in some cases, illustrative drawings. There are also references included to further reading for those who are interested in doing independent research. The riveting approach of this book is the comparison between birds and people: the similarities, differences, and relationships. I found these reflections not only thought-provoking but also helpful for discussions and debates. It is of great value to highlight that humans share the responsibility of caring for the earth. At the risk of sounding repetitive, I enjoyed the perspective the author had in her approach to writing the book. I found truly interesting her observation and inspiration in nature. I enjoyed Finnegan’s work and will be keen to read any more by this author. All in all, Birds and Humans: Who are We? by David C. Callender, is informative and enlightening as well as a thought-provoking read that readers across genres are sure to enjoy.
0 likes
about 2 years ago
Ruth FinneganDo plesse get back to me with any questions … for me or, er, for my grandfather Ruth
0 likes
about 2 years ago
About the author

I was born and brought up in Ireland, love music, nature and story-telling, have three daughters and five grandchildren. and live with my long-time husband David in Old Bletchley, southern England. I love writing, inspired by my family and the amazing natural world around me , view profile

Published on January 16, 2023

Published by Callender Press

110000 words

Genre:Nature

Reviewed by