Iconic detective Sherlock Holmes returns in Gretchen Altabef's Five Miles of Country, thrust into a compelling mystery set against the backdrop of Thomas Edison's legendary Invention Factory.
A ballerina suffers a shocking collapse while performing at Edison's New Jersey film studio. The death is immortalized on celluloid, which should make for an open-and-shut case. But clues are elusive, and Edison calls Sherlock Holmes into play to save his reputation and that of the Invention Factory.
When the word reaches Holmes, we find him suffering from the doldrums. London's crime scene has offered him little challenge of late. Dr. Watson is convinced the case will restore Holmes's sleuthing prowess and encourages him to take the case. Intrigued by the details of the crime and the fledgling film industry, Holmes decides to journey to America.
Our London criminals may have abandoned us, yet it appears, Watson, the American variate is still profoundly villainous. - Sherlock Holmes.
Once in America, Holmes and Watson travel across New York and New Jersey in search of clues against a rich canvas that stretches from the Invention Factory to Broadway to Tammany Hall.
Rising stars of the 1890s, Teddy Roosevelt and Harry Houdini, are also hand to lend nuance, color, and historical resonance.
Adding heft to the story are Holmes's wife, Irene Adler-Holmes, a Broadway diva, and his ward, Rachel Holmes, a spirited student at Vassar. The duo plays a small but crucial role, helping Holmes and Watson at critical moments in the novel.
Much appreciated is Altabef's insight into the history of cameras, filmmaking, and editing, as well as the money-making possibilities and the cut-throat competition.
Readers will enjoy the novel's Holmesian vibe, which includes many scenes of witty banter, pipe-smoking, and fireside chats. Holmes's skill with the violin even saves the day a time or two.
As always, Holmes is aided by the trusty Watson, yet they also lean on Irene, Rachel, Teddy, and Harry at pivotal times to propel the story forward. Historical novel fans will enjoy glimpses into the film industry, Broadway, New York politics, and celebrity magic.
The cause of the dancer's death is unusual--a murder born out of twisted desire with an unexpected weapon. Altabef does Sir Arthur Conan Doyle proud with a smashing conclusion.
I rate the novel four stars since I felt Holmes and Watson were part of an ensemble here rather than the focus. For me, the supporting characters are afforded too much of the spotlight. I wanted more of Holmes and Watson at center stage. The novel's secondary stories kept me from truly enjoying the gentlemen from Baker Street.
For Holmes fans and lovers of historical fiction, though, the book will feel familiar and comforting, like a visit from an old friend. The book is a pleasing homage.
I encourage Sherlock Holmes fans and enthusiasts of mysteries and thrillers to travel through Five Miles of Country. They will find the journey thrilling.