Dig, The Search For Dinosaurs by Stuart Plotkin is a creative long-form essay/journal style writing that centers on Plotkin’s previous participation in several different digs for dinosaurs of different periods. The digs take place in different states in the USA as well as Madagascar and Mongolia, and Plotkin shares his experiences as a non-professional (by which I mean non-academically trained) participant of the discovery, unearthing, and preservation process.
This book has mainly an educational purpose. Plotkin takes the time and effort in the very first couple of chapters to acquaint his readers with the geologic eras and their main characteristics, as well as which dinosaurs lived where and when and what are the main bones that are usually found. At the end of the book there is a thoughtfully placed bibliography, appendixes of questions for discussion, related websites, dinosaur jokes, a graph of geological time frame, a glossary, and a Dr. Seuss poem (not all in that order). This text contains several different styles of writing that come from seemingly separate intentions. As has been mentioned, most of it is educational, and a lot of it is quite technical to the average reader. These technical portions will always have been previously explained, but as they are important to the excavation process, and they can be quite long and often unamusing. However, Plotkin has a distinct passion for the subject material and he writes enthusiastically. This keeps his writing afloat when the subject matter otherwise seems to drag on. Plotkin’s tone is light and somewhat comedic and largely anecdotal, but there is a particular instance in which he delves into a nonsensical “thriller” story in which he is supposed to have been the only one to have watched a ghost Native American procession through the middle of the base camp one night. Considering that the text is meant to teach amateurs, this ridiculous scene is not only poorly written but largely takes away from the ulterior motive of imparting actual lessons and bits of honest education.
Dig is self-published, and it is a bit strange that it has been published on Microsoft Word using the Track Changes function. Meaning, there is a grey sidebar to the right which details a couple of format changes and indents (the changes seem to have been the last changes made before publication), but Plotkin would have benefitted largely from more in-depth editing. Additionally, some of the breaks between pieces of text are not well constructed and do not accomplish anything in terms of narrative or text structure. Sometimes the narration is broken in order to briefly refer to a specific dinosaur or to another specific aspect surrounding an excavation (for instance, the bit about schools in Madagascar). In some cases, this break would work better as a prolonged footnote or as part of an appendix.
This book is an interesting read for those who wish to acquaint themselves further with excavations and paleontology. It conveys not unsubstantial amounts of information and anecdotal experiences of digs, delivered in light banter. This text will ideally appeal to young 5th grade level readers with an interest in the study of dinosaurs. The description of digs encompasses encounters with dangerous snakes, scorpions, adverse elements such as the Mongolian steppe winds and Badlands dryness, brief histories of the locations, and the grimy conditions of excavation living quarters, as well as valuable portions relating to finding of bones (such as evaluating which ones are worth saving, and then digging, plastering, and transporting to museums or conserving in place for other excavations). There is also commentary on black market excavations and sales of dinosaur bones, which caused much trouble in Plotkin’s experience. Overall, Dig, The Search For Dinosaurs is an amusing, educational, and yet somewhat amateurish read that is worth going over if you are thinking of volunteering for an excavation some time in the future.
Book editor, freelance content writer, and translator with a literature MA. I'm passionate about all kinds of literature and art. I enjoy editing, reading, and writing creative and informative content to the best of my abilities. Originality, insight, and entertainment are priorities for me. #Scifi