Annie Oakley died 100 years ago, the woman everyone has heard of but nobody knows.
Discover the riveting story behind Little Sure Shot—and the greatest American Love Story never told.
The year is 1926, and Wild West superstar Annie Oakley knows she’s nearing her end. Confining herself to solitude, she begins a race against time to tell her husband Frank Butler why she’s never been able to say, “I love you.”
As she peels away the layers of her long-buried past—including starvation, forced labor, and sexual abuse—her Wild West created persona as the Maiden of the Prairie gives way to something deeper. Her story reveals a hardened loner who used an arsenal of wits and weapons to protect her reputation, her brand, and ultimately, her heart.
With candid honesty and poignant reflections, Annie clears the air on her unconventional marriage, her deeply spiritual friendship with Chief Sitting Bull, her uneasy alliance with the legendary Old West showman Buffalo Bill Cody, and her successful fight against the Hurst newspaper conglomerate.
Based on never-before-seen correspondence between Annie and her husband, Annie Oakley Writes of Love is a tender and harrowing rags-to-riches story behind the most famous American sharpshooter of all time.
Annie Oakley died 100 years ago, the woman everyone has heard of but nobody knows.
Discover the riveting story behind Little Sure Shot—and the greatest American Love Story never told.
The year is 1926, and Wild West superstar Annie Oakley knows she’s nearing her end. Confining herself to solitude, she begins a race against time to tell her husband Frank Butler why she’s never been able to say, “I love you.”
As she peels away the layers of her long-buried past—including starvation, forced labor, and sexual abuse—her Wild West created persona as the Maiden of the Prairie gives way to something deeper. Her story reveals a hardened loner who used an arsenal of wits and weapons to protect her reputation, her brand, and ultimately, her heart.
With candid honesty and poignant reflections, Annie clears the air on her unconventional marriage, her deeply spiritual friendship with Chief Sitting Bull, her uneasy alliance with the legendary Old West showman Buffalo Bill Cody, and her successful fight against the Hurst newspaper conglomerate.
Based on never-before-seen correspondence between Annie and her husband, Annie Oakley Writes of Love is a tender and harrowing rags-to-riches story behind the most famous American sharpshooter of all time.
I wish every married woman could look down the barrel of a gun and see her husband’s face, his lips sporting a lit cigar. Everything’s loaded to the woman’s side. Evens things out.
I loved doing that trick. The audience got quiet after Jimmie struck his match on his shoe, lit the cigar, and turned sideways to me. He would adjust his collar and tighten his tie, acting nervous. I’d raise my pistol. Aim. Lower it. Aim again. Ten thousand people held their breaths. My assistant, my Jimmie, my husband, Frank Butler, went still, cigar smoke hovering above his head. The crack of the shot. The crowd’s gasp as Jimmie twisted the ash into the sawdust. The cheering, clapping, whooping, the feet stomping on wooden bleachers, loud as a thunderstorm.
It’s easier to live in those long-ago days than face what’s ahead. Dr. Ellis comes today to give us what will surely be bad news after last week’s examinations. I’m glad he offered to come to our house since I don’t like going to his office where gawkers give me the once-over—looking for Annie Oakley, a shooting star—then glance away when they see my lined cheeks, my braced leg, and my ugly, built-up shoe.
The parlor looks good. I put flowers in vases, starched and ironed the doilies, and had the latest Bridget dust the trophy cases twice since she was too lazy to do it right the first time. We sit next to each other on the side chairs. The barber cleaned Jimmie up real nice—his thick gray curls cut tight, his mustache trimmed short, his cheeks smooth. His hands are perfectly clean. Long fingers tap on the chair arm. Legs are bent and one knee jumps. Black shoes, spit shined. Jimmie feels me looking and turns. His eyes startle me in their blueness even now, even after fifty years, and he tries to hide his fear. I swallow mine.
Ellis is fifteen minutes late. He stops dead when he is shown into the parlor and sees the mount above the fireplace.
“Good Lord! Is that a rhino?”
Jimmie stands up and takes Ellis’s hand. “Good to see you, Ellis. It’s a rhino all right. Shot it myself while on safari. Almost got that horn in my gut. But look at him now, stuffed and hanging on a wall. He’s just a rhino in Ohio.” He winks, grins.
Jimmie no more shot that rhino than flew to the moon. Neither one of us shot big game on safari. The rhino head was a gift, something everybody knows.
Because he is late, I make Ellis sit on the old chesterfield, the brass-buttoned sofa that is hard on behinds and backs. I should get rid of the thing, but our old dog Dave loved it. I see his ghost there sometimes, so it stays.
Ellis looks like he’d be happier outside, hammering nails or even breaking horses. He’s tall and rangy: his shirt cuffs fall short of his wrists, his coat is strangely worn at the lapels. He’s nearly bald, with greenish eyes behind thick glasses. Ellis don’t smile for no reason. Jimmie calls him a straight-up gent.
“How have you been?” he asks, even though he knows darn well we’re two sick old people.
“I’m all right, coughing some, but Annie is getting worse,” Jimmie says. “Look at her. She’s skinny as a broomstick and boy oh boy is she irritable.”
“I am not irritable,” I say, irritated. “You’re the one losing weight. You won’t button your coat when it’s cold, and you eat nothing but candy.”
“Not true,” says Jimmie. “I ate a pile of pancakes this morning.”
“Have you forgotten already? We had bacon and eggs this morning. I haven’t made pancakes for months. And remember, I was none too happy you fed your toast and an egg to the neighbor’s dog.”
Jimmie twists his mouth, annoyed with his forgetfulness and me, but his lips slide into a smile when he turns to the doctor. “See what I have to deal with, Dr. Ellis? She argues about everything.”
“You both could stand to gain a few pounds,” Ellis says, squirming against the lumpy sofa.
“I can’t gain weight in Ohio,” I say. “It’s too hot or too cold, and the weather changes on a dime. My body can’t adjust.”
“Here we go,” says Jimmie. “Never knew a woman who could complain about the weather like my Annie. It’s May and soft as a baby’s cheek outside, but she’ll say it’s too something. What’s wrong with the weather today, Annie?” He laughs, but then starts coughing, horrible, deep coughs that spell he is sick.
When Jimmie is able to catch his breath, Ellis says, “I contacted a throat and lung specialist in Newark. I figured you could see him when you head east. When did you say you’re going?”
“Not before fall,” Jimmie says, looking womanish as he dabs his watery eyes with his hanky.
“Should be sooner.” Ellis swallows whatever else he was going to say, but his worried look says more than words.
“It’s not just the coughing,” I say. “He forgets to put on his pants some mornings. Last week, he said I should wash off the greasepaint on my face because I looked too white. I’ve never worn a speck of greasepaint, as he should know. He sits by the window for hours waiting for our setter to come trotting down the driveway. When I tell him Dave’s dead and gone, he cries like the dog died yesterday.”
Jimmie whispers, “I know he’s dead.” I worry he’s going to cry in front of Ellis. Lord how I hate how Jimmie cries at the drop of a hat, but maybe it’s better if Ellis gets the full picture. My husband’s hands clutch each other, something he does when he wants to control himself.
“We all get forgetful in our old age,” says Ellis, who’s probably tired of our arguing. He has given in to the chesterfield. He faces Jimmie and asks, “Remind me, how old are you?”
“Seventy-six, seven. Somewhere around there. It’s one of those things I like to forget,” and doesn’t he give Ellis another grin and a wink that says, Everything’s fine, Doc. Don’t worry about me.
But I know different. My Irish husband with the gift of gab has got quiet, like he ran out of talk. Sometimes, he searches for words and they duck his tongue in a mean game of hide-and-seek. I wish Ellis could see that Jimmie’s grins and winks are cover for his wandering mind. But Jimmie is in fine fettle today.
I pull out my embroidery hoop with the linen napkin I’m monogramming for my niece who is marrying some fool next month. I thread the needle with red floss, jab the white cloth, and wait for what I know is coming.
“Your anemia is getting worse, Annie,” Ellis says. “The blood test shows it’s a wonder you’re still upright. Are you sucking on nails and cooking in cast iron like I told you?”
“Yes,” I lie, “every day.”
“No, she doesn’t,” Jimmie says. He’s getting back at me for what I’ve told Ellis about crying over the dog. He walks to the mantel and stands under the rhino head. I shoot him a look that could curdle milk.
I try not to sound snappish, but it’s no use. “I do too, just not when you’re around.” We’d fought about the nails, which Jimmie left in piles all over the house so I’d have no excuse not to suck on one every waking minute. I couldn’t stand the feel of an iron nail in my mouth, hitting my teeth. Dumbest treatment I ever heard of. I punch the needle through the tight fabric on my hoop and almost stab myself.
“You know you really need a transfusion,” Ellis says. “It could give you time, a year. Maybe two.”
I hear Jimmie gasp, and when I look up from my hoop, he is as white as the linen in my lap. I could wring Ellis’s neck.
“What’s this about a year?” Jimmie asks Ellis. “I didn’t know she was that sick.”
I look up from my hands and hiss at Ellis, “I told you not to bring this up because there’s no point. I’m not having someone else’s blood in my veins. I hate the thought of it.”
“I thought he should know,” says Ellis.
Jimmie goes back to his chair and pulls it closer to me. He tries to take my hand off my hoop, but I shake him off.
“You work on her,” Ellis says. “I’ve talked myself blue, but she won’t listen to me.”
“You think she listens to me?” says Jimmie, sounding like every man who complains about his wife. Ellis tries not to smile. They are in cahoots. It gets too quiet.
“Why didn’t you tell me?” Jimmie’s voice is soft, hurt, and afraid, and Ellis is watching, waiting for my answer.
How can I say that I’m afraid of telling my husband? I’m afraid of the transfusion, and I’m afraid of dying. I’m afraid of being alone. Most of all, I’m afraid to admit that I’m afraid. I can’t be weak now. I need them to back off, so I bark good and loud, “I didn’t tell you because I knew you’d be upset! And that you’d hound me like a dog on a bear. I’m not getting a transfusion, so you can both shut your traps!”
I feel the rhino watching us with his beady little glass eyes and sneery double horn and take a deep breath to calm down. I set my hoop aside and struggle to my feet. This visit is over.
I expect Ellis to free himself from the chesterfield, but he stays. He clears his throat and says, “This is hard for me to say and will be harder for you to hear. I think you two are making each other sicker. You are worrying yourselves to death. I want you to consider separating for a few months so you can each work on your own health.”
Jimmie is wearing a surprised look, no doubt the mirror of mine.
“We’ll think about it,” he says.
Ellis goes on, “Just for a few months. I really think it would help both of you.”
“I said we’ll think about it,” says Jimmie. There is steel in his voice. It’s how he sounds when he gets advice he doesn’t like.
Ellis nods at the two of us, grabs his hat and leaves, promising to swing by later in the week with the address of the throat specialist.
With the doctor gone, we are back to our private selves. I snap, “You shouldn’t have told him about the nails.”
“I’m sorry. I’m worried. But you shouldn’t have brought up Dave in front of Ellis.”
“Right. Shouldn’t have. I can’t talk right now. Too tired,” I say.
“We could both use a chair nap,” he says, and I agree.
My husband can fall asleep in an instant and anywhere. He stretches out and closes his eyes, his head falling back on the antimacassar. His face is unlined in sleep, his cheeks flushed; his eyelashes are still black, but his brows are gone gray. His hands are quiet and rest on his long legs. He is my Jimmie, my name for him since we first met. (His name for me is Missie, picked up from my Wild West days.) How handsome he still is. How long I have loved looking at him. Lord, Lord, what are we going to do?
While he sleeps, I finish the napkin’s second initial, P for Peterson. A marriage starts, a marriage ends. When Jimmie wakes up, he says he will spend the rest of the day working on the car. I have time alone to think.
I make cowboy beans for supper, a meal Jimmie loves and I can’t stand. Ate too many bean meals as a child and later, during those Wild West years, but every so often I make them, usually when we aren’t getting along, a peace offering. I make corn bread, put butter, jam, and pickles on the table. Jimmie gives me a big smile when he finally comes inside and sniffs at the pot of beans.
“Missie,” he says, “have you made those beans just for me?”
“I surely have. Even though you know how I feel about beans and what they do to my innards.”
“I do indeed,” he says.
At supper, he tucks into his piled-high plate and eats like a starving man, just to please me. I push three beans around the bread and eat a small piece of pickle.
“You know,” Jimmie says between bites, “we could head south in early August. After a stop in Detroit to see Hulda. We’d go on to Newark, finish up our wills and be down in North Carolina by September.”
“What about what Ellis said? About being apart.”
“He’s full of beans.” He grins. “What does he know?”
I think Ellis knows quite a bit about us. And I think he is right. We should separate, because we’re making each other sicker. We’re both afraid of what’s coming: not death, but watching it come for one of us, leaving the other behind. We are rubbing each other raw with worry.
“He might be right, but for the wrong reasons.” I butter my corn bread and force down a bite. I try to sound as if I haven’t been thinking of my plan for hours, weighing options, wondering how he will react.
I busy myself moving from the table to the sink with our plates and put the leftovers in the icebox. I am working at sounding like I don’t really care what we do.
“We could get a lot done between now and the fall if we’re apart, you going first. I could get back to my autobiography. With you gone, I bet I could start again, maybe finish the dang thing.”
He is frowning. I talk louder, faster, knowing he hears what I don’t say. “I can’t write with you over my shoulder making comments and corrections. I’ll do much better alone. You can visit Hulda in Detroit, then go to Newark to that throat specialist, see what he says. And by the way, while you’re in Newark, get those teeth worked on. I’ll meet you in North Carolina in September.”
“Sounds like you have it all planned out,” says Jimmie, pushing his plate away. “Sounds like you can’t wait for me to be out of your hair.”
“It’s just one way of looking at it,” I say, and let the subject drop.
I bring a rhubarb pie to the table along with some vanilla ice cream I had delivered special. We eat and talk of other things, mainly about Hammy, the neighbor’s wormy dog, who visits us at breakfast.
We go to bed early. The spring sun has barely set, and our room is stuffy, even with the window open. The peepers are making a racket. Jimmie and I hold hands and watch the darkness fill the room. I hear a moth fluttering against the window frame, trying to escape, even though the window is open right in front of her. Just when I am sure Jimmie has dropped off to sleep, he squeezes my hand and says, “We need to talk.” I don’t say anything, and then he adds, “I love you, Missie.”
I squeeze his hand back and say, “We’ll talk tomorrow.” And I roll over, my cold back to him.
I can’t sleep. I am boiled up. I want to tell Jimmie I love him, but the words clog my throat. I don’t know why. I know it hurts him that I won’t say those love words. He could use them after today. He could have used them many times over our fifty years together, but I’ve never said them. I’ve tried a thousand times to explain, but too much happened before I met him, and he knows almost nothing of it. I can show tenderness to orphans, sick children, say “I love you” to skinny horses and mangy dogs, but not to Jimmie. Never to Jimmie. In the early days, when he’d press me to say it, we’d go around and around. I love you, Missie. Do you love me? Yes, Jimmie, of course I do. Well then why can’t you just say it? I don’t know! Don’t try to put words in my mouth!
When did he stop trying to get me to say I love you? When did he give up? He said once that I was too stubborn for my own good, and I think he thought that’s what it was, just me being stubborn and refusing him what he wanted. What he didn’t know was that it wasn’t that I wouldn’t give him what he wanted. I couldn’t. Tonight, in the soft dark, I cannot hide from my brittle heart.
The frogs quiet down, and I think of Jimmie leaving me in Ohio, all alone, sick, maybe soon on my way out of this world. Him sick too. Are we both really dying? Could we die apart after all these years together? No, that is foolishness. We wouldn’t let that happen. These days, we can get to one another in hours, or at worst, a couple of days depending on the train schedule. But the idea of parting scares me.
We don’t have much more time, and I want him to know me, really know me. Everything, everything, all my secrets. All my shame. How to tell him? The words won’t come. I want my tired old blood to carry my story and love through the skin of my fingers and into him so I won’t have to struggle with all I’d like to say. Do they have love transfusions? I imagine Jimmie and I hooked up together, tubes of blood pulsing between us. Our hearts beating in time with one another: I love you I love you I love you.
I wave my arm to shoo the caught moth toward the night air. But she pushes harder into the window frame edge, her powdery wings beating against the wood. I, too, am a frightened creature trying to find a way out. I have cornered myself in by simply being me, cold and hard, no nonsense, no tears, no softness—my corner, where I am protected and trapped. Before she batters herself to death, I blow kisses at her, and the moth breaks free and heads toward the moon.
With her escape, I feel hope in the night breeze. If I told Jimmie my story, all of it, maybe he’d understand why, when he most needs me, I lock up like a safe. Maybe I would understand, too. I have nothing more to lose. It’s time to get to the bottom of me before it’s too late.
I think of the beginning of my life’s story, a mess of scribbles, a book I started and put aside years ago. Where is that box?
My mind races. With Jimmie away, I will have a last chance to figure this out for both of us before I face the Lord or before he does. But I know in my bones I will die first.
I am surprised by the moth, who returns and lands on my cheek, softer than a kiss. I smile before she leaves me again. My mind and my heart settle. I feel His peacefulness, and I start my travel to sleep.
I crawl back to awake when I feel Jimmie’s hand on my shoulder.
“Missie, do you want me to go?” His voice is raw, and I know my answer will hurt him.
“Ellis thinks it’s best. Just for a few months.”
“But do you want me to go?”
Before he asks again, I pat his hand and say, “Yes, I want you to go.”
Annie Oakley, America’s shooting sweetheart, and her beloved husband Frank Butler struggle with health issues in their later year, forcing them to confront the reality that they have limited time left on earth. However, Annie still hasn’t finished writing her autobiography. Concluding that their intense desperation to worry about each other hastens their decline, Annie separates from Frank to focus on this final task, writing him letters intermittently to report her progress. Author D.K. Kennedy’s historical fiction novel pieces together Annie Oakley’s rags-to-riches success story while beautifully tracing the parallel romance story that started it all. Annie Oakley Writes of Love is a worthy tribute to her iconic role as a gun-toting, horse-riding performer in Wild West shows during the late 1800s.
Kennedy authentically recreates Oakley’s first-person voice while incorporating real-life events from her life. In doing so, Kennedy achieves a strong balance between Oakley’s colloquialisms and lyrical writing; the novel reads like literary fiction, achieving beauty without sacrificing clarity. To aid in the realism, she includes imagined details about Oakley and Butler's infamous marriage where primary source records and already-published biographies are sparse. Interspersed between prose narration, fictionalized letters between “Missie” and “Jimmie” (their pet names for each other) appear alongside occasional news articles. The storyline’s reveals paint an image of a loving partnership between Oakley and Butler, despite their unconventional marriage. “When I look at my past,” Annie writes in a letter to Frank, “it’s like Mr. Edison’s movie, but instead of a grown woman, I see a girl, small for her age, a lot of times dirty, hungry and lonely enough to die.” Oakley confesses that certain behaviors in their marriage connect to these traumas, warning Jimmie, “there are things I never told you. Some of it’s pretty rotten.”
At the same time, the beauty of Oakley’s success story outweighs the ugliness of her past. Readers should expect disturbing details in Oakley’s beginnings and, given the time period, obvious misogyny in the way she is treated as a performer and a woman. The book also represents a time period in which Native Americans were referred to as “Indians” and were treated by the general American population with irreverence and discrimination. However, the author tempers these moments by allowing Oakley’s encounters with Sitting Bull to convey a more humane view without reframing her historical role. In addition, Annie’s life as an international traveler and her work to empower other women lends incredible depth to her story as a woman with opinions and experiences before her time. Readers interested in women’s fiction and history will enjoy this novelized version of Annie Oakley’s life. In addition, the book may appeal to readers of realistic romance and literary fiction. Altogether, it’s a highly recommended page-turner and well worth the read.